Ben Nelson's planned retirement: A big blow to Dems?

The Nebraska senator won't seek a third term, raising questions about the Left's chances of holding onto its slim Senate majority

Best Opinion:  Bloomberg, Hot Air, Daily Kos

Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid may have trouble hanging onto his majority title in the 113th Congress. On Tuesday, Sen. Ben Nelson (D-Neb.) became the latest moderate Democrat (following Kent Conrad and Jim Webb, among others) to announce that he won't seek another term in the 2012 election. Nelson, who faced an uphill battle for a third term, is the sole Democrat in Nebraska's five-member congressional delegation, and many political analysts believe his red-state seat could now be a relatively easy Republican pickup. The GOP is working hard to wrest control of the Senate from the Dems in 2012, and only has to net four seats to flip the Dems' 53-47 majority in the 100-member Senate. Is Nelson's retirement a "significant blow" to Dems, or no biggie since he would have likely lost his re-election bid anyway?

This is a big loss for Dems: Nelson's retirement "puts Republicans one seat closer to a majority," Cook Political Report's Jennifer Duffy tells Bloomberg. I simply "don't see a path to victory for Democrats in Nebraska." Nelson is hardly perfect, Rothenberg Political Report's Nathan Gonzales tells Bloomberg, but he was the Dems' best bet in the Cornhusker State. And remember, Democrats are already "defending eight out of the 10 most competitive seats in the country." This is a "significant blow" in the Left's quest to keep the Senate.
"Nelson's retirement hurts Senate Dems' in 2012"

But Nelson would have lost anyway: This isn't such a big deal, says Ed Morrissey at Hot Air. Though I'm reluctant "to underestimate the power of incumbency," you can bet Nelson wouldn't have been re-elected in this "very red state." "The man couldn't even eat a pizza in peace after casting a decisive vote for ObamaCare and tossing his pro-life credentials into the wastebasket by doing so." He would have surely been replaced by "a credible Republican candidate." This development doesn't change "the calculus in Nebraska."
"Breaking: Nelson to retire"

This might even be good for Dems: Of course, this looks "like a very tough break for Team Blue," says David Nir at Daily Kos. But there could be "a silver lining." If "Nelson really had no hope of winning another term, then a ton of resources would have been wasted on a futile attempt to save him." Now, if losing his seat is a foregone conclusion, Democrats can focus on defending seats they actually have a chance of keeping, not to mention helping new candidates, like Shelley Berkley in Nevada and Elizabeth Warren in Massachusetts. They actually stand a chance of picking up new seats for the Dems.
"NE-Sen: Democrat Ben Nelson reportedly will announce retirement"

see 5 comments

Elizabeth Warren's 'kick-ass' class warfare rebuttal

The progressive hero and Massachusetts Senate hopeful impresses pundits and prospective voters with a powerful defense of liberal politics

The video: Elizabeth Warren, the polarizing consumer advocate who's challenging Republican Sen. Scott Brown for the Massachusetts Senate seat Ted Kennedy held for nearly five decades, is already whipping up excitement on the Left. After announcing her candidacy... More

What the Dems' 'humiliating' NY-09 loss means for 2012

Republican Bob Turner pulls off a shocking upset in a longtime Democratic stronghold in New York City. Does this spell trouble for President Obama?

Republican political newbie Bob Turner delivered a stunning blow to Democrats in a special election Tuesday, handily beating Democratic state Assemblyman David Weprin and putting New York's 9th Congressional District into GOP hands for the first time since 1923... More

Dems might lose Anthony Weiner's seat: Blame Obama?

A Republican political newbie is poised to pull off a major upset in a New York congressional district that's been in Democratic hands since 1923

Democrats have gone into panic mode in the New York race to replace disgraced former Rep. Anthony Weiner. Little-known Republican businessman Bob Turner has surged into a polling lead over Democratic state Assemblyman David Weprin ahead of Tuesday's special... More

Gabrielle Giffords' surprise return: Proof that she's running in 2012?

The recovering congresswoman's emotional visit to the House floor Monday night warmed a cynical nation — and fueled speculation about her future

Rep. Gabrielle Giffords (D-Ariz.) surprised colleagues with an emotional return to the House floor Monday night to cast her vote on the debt ceiling bill. Beyond adding a veneer of class to the ugly debt-limit fight, her return fueled speculation that she... More

Sex scandal: Should Democrat David Wu resign?

The Oregon congressman says he won't quit, despite allegations that he had an "unwanted sexual encounter" with a donor's teenage daughter

Democratic leaders in the House are calling for an ethics investigation of Rep. David Wu (D-Ore.), following reports that he had an "unwanted sexual encounter" with a donor's teenage daughter. Wu has grown increasingly unpopular in his district, following reports... More