Should pregnancy be labeled a disability?

An Ohio professor argues that expectant moms need legal protection so the strains of pregnancy don't cost them their jobs

Best Opinion:  Univ. of Dayton, The Stir, Babble

Dizziness, weight gain, sleeplessness, aches, fatigue, nausea — those are just some of the uncomfortable issues that pregnant women deal with. And taken together, argues Jeanette Cox, an associate law professor at Ohio' s University of Dayton law school, these conditions are the rough equivalent of a minor disability. Cox contends that the feds should expand the Americans with Disabilities act to include pregnant women — and better protect their rights on the job. Is she right?

Absolutely: The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) already protects those "with minor temporary physical limitations comparable to pregnancy's physical effects," Cox tells the University of Dayton. But because pregnancy is not specifically protected by the ADA, millions of expectant mothers don't get the same legal rights as people with similar physical impairments do. Women sometimes lose their jobs because of pregnancy. For example, one retail worker was let go "because drinking water while working to maintain a healthy pregnancy violated store policy." The law must be changed to prevent such outrages.
"Is pregnancy a disability?"

No way: This idea, while "well-intentioned," would be "one hell of a slippery slope," says Linda Sharps at The Stir. "For most of us, pregnancy is a normal, healthy condition, not a disability." It's always nice to get a bit of special treatment during pregnancy — be it a seat on the subway or a good parking space — but it's hardly necessary. Let's just keep relying on the Pregnancy Discrimination Act to ensure that pregnant women are treated fairly at work. "Labeling every pregnancy as a physical impairment seems like the wrong thing to do."
"Pregnancy shouldn't be called a disability"

But it might be necessary: "Before you leap up in outrage at the idea that pregnant women might be considered disabled, think about what the legal protection would mean," says Sierra at Babble. Pregnant women do need to be accommodated on the job, from having adequate access to drinking water and sufficient bathroom breaks to sometimes being given a lighter load. Maybe Cox's solution isn't the perfect one. But make no mistake: "Working pregnant women often have a problem getting fair treatment from their employers." That must change.
"Is pregnancy a disability?"

see 10 comments

A restaurant's 'outrageous' 'baby tax'

An English eatery sparks an international debate by charging moms an extra $5 for bringing young children to the table

An Asian buffet restaurant in South London has ignited a controversy that has parents across the pond shaking their fists in anger. Multiple mothers say that when they took their babies to the Cosmo restaurant — an 800-seat, 22,000-square-foot venue billed... More

Should sex educators teach kids about pleasure?

Abstinence-based sex ed has failed, argue some parents. It's high time we started being far more honest about the birds and the bees

The cover story in Sunday's New York Times Magazine profiles a Pennsylvania sex-ed teacher who has abandoned the usual "sex is dangerous, don't do it, but if you must, use a condom approach." Instead, Al Vernacchio aims for candor, telling tells his ninth- and... More

A 20th baby for the Duggars: Too risky?

Though her last pregnancy was fraught with dangerous complications, Michelle Duggar of 19 Kids and Counting is excited to have No. 20 on the way

On Tuesday, an excited Michelle and Jim Bob Duggar of the TLC reality show 19 Kids and Counting announced that they are expecting their twentieth child. Commentators were less buoyant: After all, Michelle's last pregnancy was a complicated one, leading to the premature... More

To Train Up A Child: The book that's leading parents to kill?

Pastor Michael Pearl defends his corporal punishment guide after it is found in the homes of three children who died from alleged abuse

A Tennessee preacher and corporal punishment advocate is coming under intense criticism after copies of his self-published book, To Train Up a Child, were found in three homes where children died from alleged abuse. In his book, pastor Michael Pearl advises parents... More

The Texas judge who whipped his daughter: When is spanking child abuse?

A woman reignites a debate over parental discipline by posting a years-old video of her dad, a Texas judge, ferociously whipping her with his belt

The debate over spanking flared up this week, after a 23-year-old Texas woman posted a 7:35 minute video (that has since gone viral on YouTube) showing her father hitting her repeatedly with powerful belt lashes. The video was recorded seven years ago, when Hillary... More