Team Romney claims Mitt saved GM: 'The height of hypocrisy'?

The Romney camp boasts that GM survived bankruptcy only because President Obama followed the GOP candidate's advice. Really?

Best Opinion:  Salon, New Republic, Investor's Business Daily

Mitt Romney's campaign has news for you: It was Romney, not President Obama, who saved the U.S. auto industry. This week, Romney's campaign manager, Eric Fehrnstrom, said the reason General Motors and Chrysler survived the recession is because Obama followed Romney's prescription to put the automakers through a "managed bankruptcy process." That means "the only economic success that President Obama has had," Fehrnstrom said, "is because he followed Mitt Romney's advice." Fehrnstrom is referring to a New York Times editorial that Romney penned in 2008, in which he called for a "managed bankruptcy" of the two auto giants. Critics were quick to deride Fehrnstrom's claim as "mindboggling" and "the height of hypocrisy." Did Obama really follow Romney's lead on GM?

No. This claim is preposterous: We have no reason to believe Obama was influenced by Romney's op-ed, says Steve Kornacki at Salon. And remember, Romney opposed the hefty bailouts that the government extended to GM and Chrysler, which were crucial in saving the companies from bankruptcy. In late 2008 and early 2009, credit markets were in a deep freeze, and private companies were in no position to finance Detroit's restructuring. Romney might have "broadly advocated the course that Obama followed," but "specifically condemned vital components" that led to the revival of the U.S. auto industry.
"The bailout Mitt suddenly loves"

Romney is just shape-shifting again: "Mitt Romney, who was for the auto bailout before he was against it, is back to being for it," says Jonathan Cohn at The New Republic. Once the GOP primaries got underway, he attacked Obama for risking taxpayer dollars, a popular position with conservatives. But during the February primary in car-loving Michigan, he backtracked, saying he "would never have let the companies go bankrupt." Now that the general election is nearing, he's "backtracking all the way," but only because Obama is enjoying the political fruit of saving the two companies.
"Romney on the auto bailout, version 3.0"

But Obama hasn't been honest about the bailouts either: "The Obama camp can't stop clucking about how he saved GM and the car industry," but the bailout was hardly a ringing success, says Investor's Business Daily in an editorial. The government still owns a huge chunk of GM, and the company still owes the Treasury billions of dollars. "Taxpayers have not been paid back and are still on the hook as GM continues to require government help." If that is how Obama defines success, it "speaks volumes about his policies."
"Obama pushes false GM success story"

 

Dan Akerson's $7.7 million salary: Is the GM boss underpaid?

The auto giant says its chief steered the company to a record profit last year, and complains that government pay caps prevent him from receiving his due

General Motors had a historically successful year in 2011, posting a record $7.6 billion profit. It's a robust turnaround for the once-enfeebled company, which needed a hefty cash injection from the government to avoid going under, and is still partly owned by...

More

GM's new self-driving pod car

The hands-free two-wheeler will be able to park itself, and come when you call it by smartphone

The image: General Motors reportedly plans to start selling a two-seat, self-steering electric "pod" car around 2020. GM developed the design of the futuristic "Electric Network Vehicle" (EN-V) with the help of Segway, and the car balances itself using the same... More

GM turns a profit: Why isn't that good news?

The Detroit automaker turned its first profit since 2004, but saw shares slump almost immediately. Why isn't the market encouraged that GM's back in the black?

On Thursday, GM reported its first annual profit in six years — earning $4.7 billion on $136 billion in sales — exceeding expectations and continuing its impressive rebound from government-assisted bankruptcy. Great news, right? Investors didn't see... More

Will GM benefit from a woman's touch?

GM's new product-development chief, Mary Barra, is the first female to hold that post for any American car company. Is her gender relevant?

GM chief executive Dan Akerson is making some bold changes at the newly profitable auto giant, but perhaps the most "surprising" was his decision on Thursday to name Mary Barra as GM's first female product development czar. Barra, a 30-year GM veteran who is currently... More

GM's IPO: A victory for Obama?

The automaker's public offering was a tremendous success. Does it also count as a big win for the White House?

President Obama hailed GM's return to majority private ownership Thursday, saying the automaker's better-than-expected IPO vindicated his "tough" and much-maligned decisions to rescue the bankrupt company. Had he listened to the "doubters and naysayers" who... More