Arizona's immigration law: A Supreme Court disaster for Obama?

The high court appears ready to uphold parts of a controversial law that the president opposes, which could be a major setback for his re-election campaign

Best Opinion:  Bloomberg, Politico, SCOTUSblog

For the second time in as many months, President Obama is clashing with the highest court in the land. In March, skeptical conservatives on the Supreme Court appeared to doubt the constitutionality of Obama's 2010 health care overhaul. And this week, the court seemed ready to uphold the most controversial provision of S.B. 1070, a tough immigration law that Arizona passed in 2010. The provision in question requires police officers to determine the immigration status of any person they "reasonably" suspect is an illegal immigrant, which critics (including the president's Justice Department) say will encourage racial profiling of Latinos. And even liberal members of the court had trouble swallowing the Obama administration's argument that Arizona was usurping the federal government's right to set immigration policy. Is Obama facing a Supreme Court disaster?

The court could really damage his campaign: Obama "faces the specter of twin setbacks" when the court hands down its decisions on ObamaCare and Arizona's immigration law in June, says Greg Stohr at Bloomberg News. The court may throw its venerable weight behind two conservative positions, a "one-two punch" that could leave the Obama campaign reeling. And the two cases share a common theme — the argument that the feds were overstepping their power on both health care and immigration — that conservatives are bound to highlight in the fight against Obama.
"High court skeptical of Obama's use of power"

Actually, a defeat for Obama is a powerful campaign tool: While losing the Arizona case could cause Obama "some embarrassment," it would likely help him in November, says Josh Gerstein at Politico. Latinos and immigration-rights groups "are no fans" of the administration's deportation policies, but a win for Arizona "could produce a wave of alarm in Latino communities." Obama stands to benefit "for having led the fight to knock the legislation out in the courts."
"5 takeaways from Arizona immigration law showdown"

The battle over Arizona's law won't end here: The Obama administration argued that Arizona had infringed on the federal government's purview, says Lyle Denniston at SCOTUSblog, but it did not challenge the law on discriminatory grounds, effectively ignoring the compelling argument that the law gives "police authority to arrest and detain people just because they look like foreigners." Indeed, Chief Justice John Roberts deliberately clarified that the use-of-power debate was distinct from the issue of racial profiling. But civil-rights challenges to the law are swimming around lower courts, and the Obama administration could very well take up that fight if parts of S.B. 1070 are upheld. Stay tuned.
"Argument recap: A choice between radical and reasonable?"

 

Did Mexican drug lords really put a bounty on Sheriff Joe Arpaio?

Arizona's "toughest sheriff" says Mexican drug cartels are offering $1 million for his murder. Is this a PR-stunt or proof that his hard-line tactics work?

Arizona's notoriously tough and media-savvy Sheriff Joe Arpaio says Mexican drug cartels have put a $1 million bounty on his head, presumably for his trademark sweeps for illegal immigrants in Latino areas of Maricopa County. The threat was delivered via a slightly... More

Arizona's immigration law: Is it dead?

A judge blocks controversial parts of Arizona's immigration crackdown a day before they were to take effect — but some commentators say the fight has just begun

In what immigrant advocates call a major victory, a federal judge blocked the most controversial parts of Arizona's hardline immigration law hours before they were to take effect. Judge Susan Bolton ruled on Wednesday that certain "unconstitutional" provisions... More

Is Arizona's immigration law already a success?

Illegal immigrants are reportedly rushing to get out of Arizona before the state's tough new law takes effect. Proof of concept, say supporters

Illegal immigrants are reportedly fleeing Arizona this week, trying to avoid getting caught when the state's tough new immigration law takes effect on Thursday, making it a crime to be in the state without proper papers and requiring police to investigate suspected... More

Neo-Nazis at the Mexican border

As if Arizona's new immigration law weren't controversial enough, heavily armed white supremacists have decided to help "secure the border"

Arizona's controversial new immigration law calls for local law enforcement to fight illegal immigration, but apparently local neo-Nazis want in on the action, too. Jason "J.T." Ready, 37 — who claims ties to the white supremacist National Socialist Movement... More

Is Obama's Arizona suit 'toxic' for Dems?

Some Democratic governors think the White House's battle over Arizona's immigration law will cripple the party in this fall's midterm elections

At a private White House meeting this weekend, a group of Democratic governors expressed "deep anxiety" about the Obama administration's lawsuit against Arizona's new immigration law and its effects on the November election. "It is such a toxic subject," Tennessee... More