The high-stakes Iran nuclear summit: Is a deal possible?

This weekend, Iranian leaders will try to hash out their differences with Western powers. Only the most persistent optimists expect a true breakthrough

Best Opinion:  Wash. Post, Slate, RealClearPolitics

Iran and the P5+1 nations — permanent U.N. Security Council members America, Russia, China, France, and England, and Germany — are holding talks this weekend over Iran's nuclear program. The Istanbul summit represents the first Iran nuclear talks in a year and a half, but expectations for a breakthrough aren't especially high, given the players' competing interests and goals, the looming U.S. presidential election, and past negotiating failures. At the same time, crippling economic sanctions are inflicting real pain on Iran, and Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei recently stated that nuclear weapons are "a grave sin," and "logically, religiously and theoretically" antithetical to the Iranian regime. Might diplomacy prevail?

We might just see a breakthrough: "There is too much pessimism in the air" about these talks, says Fareed Zakaria in The Washington Post. "A robust deal is possible," if everyone gets something they want. Perhaps Iran will allow unfettered U.N. nuclear inspections, and the West will let Iran develop civilian nuclear power but no weapons, while easing sanctions as the U.N. team ensures compliance. Iran's hardliners are apparently on board, so the "most formidable" obstacle may be convincing Washington.
"The shape of a deal with Iran"

Huh? These talks are hopeless: Nothing is going to happen in Istanbul, says Fred Kaplan at Slate. Iran is led by "messianic fundamentalists," and no matter what they say, "the Iranians want a pocketful of nuclear weapons." And look, even if Tehran is serious about a deal, "it's hard to envision" one that would satisfy both Iran and Israel. Of course, if there's a diplomatic route to keeping Iran nuke-free, "it's worth pursuing, at some effort and cost." But such a patch is very difficult for me to imagine.
"October surprise"

We need a broader vision for Iran: "Nobody can predict where the process of negotiation with Iran is headed," but "Istanbul is a fragile beginning," at best, says David Ignatius at RealClearPolitics. What's needed is "a serious exercise of diplomacy," and the man with a plan is, oddly, Henry Kissinger. He rightly believes that the best way to tame revolutionary Iran is to persuade it to operate "as a nation rather than a cause," and bring it into a new rules-based Mideast "concert of nations" that accepts Iran's rise but limits its "most harmful effects." If "this happens, Iran can be a force for regional stability, not disorder."
"Kissinger's model for a stable Iran"

 

Obama's Israel summit: Did it reduce the risk of war with Iran?

Israel is eager to launch a military strike against Iran's nuclear facilities — and Obama seems equally eager to talk the Israeli prime minister out of it

At a White House summit Monday with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, President Obama urged Israel to refrain from attacking Iran's suspected nuclear weapons program, saying Israel should first give tough new sanctions a chance to weaken the... More

How badly will Iran's oil 'blackmail' hurt Europe?

Tehran cuts off oil shipments to the U.K. and France in retaliation for Western sanctions over Iran's nuclear program. Is this bad for the EU ... or Iran?

Iran has cut off oil shipments to France and Britain in retaliation for tough new sanctions from Europe, which, starting July 1, will impose an embargo on Iranian oil, a crucial source of revenue for Tehran, in an attempt to force Iran to curb its nuclear program... More

Would Israel attack Iran without U.S. approval?

Ehud Barak and Co. are ratcheting up their rhetoric as Iran's nuclear program continues unchecked — and many U.S. officials don't think our allies are bluffing

Israeli leaders are delivering their "bluntest warnings" yet of possible airstrikes to disable Iran's nuclear program, something the U.S. and other Western leaders fear would uncork dangerous turmoil in the Middle East. Israeli Defense Minister Ehud Barak says... More

Iran's nuclear threat: Can inspections defuse the tensions?

Many Western diplomats hope their worst fears won't be confirmed as international nuclear experts arrive in Iran for a fact-finding mission

A team of inspectors from the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) began a potentially crucial three-day visit to Iran on Sunday. Tehran's top diplomat said he was confident that talks between inspectors and Iranian officials would soothe foreign leaders,... More

Iran's offer to talk nukes: A win for the West?

Tehran says it's willing to resume discussions, but insists it won't cave to foreign demands that it stop enriching uranium

Facing a potentially devastating oil embargo, Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad said Thursday that his government was ready to resume talks with foreign leaders who want to curb Iran's controversial nuclear program. But Ahmadinejad said international pressure... More