Airplane Safety

Opinion Brief

Will airlines finally stop forcing fliers to turn off their iPads?

Travelers rejoice as the government reconsiders much-hated rules requiring passengers to turn off their gadgets during taxi, takeoff, and landing

Soon there may be no need to power down your iPad during takeoff and landing, as the government is considering a reversal on its widely-loathed rule.

Soon there may be no need to power down your iPad during takeoff and landing, as the government is considering a reversal on its widely-loathed rule. Photo: WESTEND61/Westend61/Corbis SEE ALL 39 PHOTOS

Best Opinion:  Gizmodo, N.Y. Times, DailyTech

Alec Baldwin is hardly the only air traveler who doesn't like it when a flight attendant announces that all electronic devices must be powered down prior to takeoff. Experts and frequent fliers have long suspected that the rule — which ostensibly prevents our gadgets from interfering with the plane's complex equipment — is unnecessary, and might have been created just to torture us. After all, pilots are allowed to use iPads in the cockpit, so why can't we? Well, happier flights might be on the horizon: The Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) is giving the rules a "fresh look" to determine whether e-readers and tablets (but not smartphones) actually interfere with plane avionics. Will gadgets soon be welcome aboard?

Yes. And change can't come fast enough: "About. Bloody. Time," says Jamie Condliffe at Gizmodo. "Everybody hates having to stop reading e-books, listening to music, and playing Angry Birds during takeoff." It's been six years since the FAA last conducted a study on whether electronic devices mess with plane equipment, and in the meantime, the number of "passenger bags containing Kindles" has soared. "This time we might actually see a change."
"The FAA may soon allow electronic device use during takeoff"

It still might take a while. A long while: Don't blow past the bookstore at the airport "and start using your Kindle during takeoff just yet," says Nick Bilton at The New York Times. Airlines will have to go through plenty of "bureaucratic red tape" before they can allow passengers to use their devices uninterrupted. Under FAA rules, every airline (from JetBlue to United) will have to test every single device (that means the iPad, the iPad 2, and the newest iPad) in every single plane model. So don't hold your breath.
"Time to review FAA policy on gadgets"

At least we'll finally get to the bottom of this: It's unclear when exactly our iPads will get the all-clear, but we should all be glad that we'll "finally confirm or deny whether these devices pose any sort of threat at all," says Tiffany Kaiser at DailyTech. There is scant evidence that e-readers and tablets pose any harm. Most planes must be able to "withstand 100 volts per meter of electrical interference," and the Kindle unleashes a grand total of 30 microvolts per meter (which is 0.00003 of a volt for those who are counting). That's hardly a safety risk.
"FAA to review rules regarding table/e-reader use during takeoff, landing"

 
Comment Print
opinion brief

Do gadgets really need to be turned off during flights?

With holiday travel season upon us, many fliers are questioning whether they must truly shut down their iPads before takeoff

The rule that passengers must shut down their electronics during takeoff and landing may appear pointless to many fliers, but some say it's better to be safe than sorry.

"Ladies and gentleman, we'll be landing soon. All electronic devices must now be powered off." That familiar, groan-inducing announcement is heard on just about every commercial flight. But is it necessary? Can a laptop really screw up a jumbo jet's communication... More

opinion brief

TSA airport screening: Are we safe enough to keep our shoes on?

The days of walking through security checkpoints in your socks might be ending. Too soon or long overdue?

A passenger removes his shoes at the Sacramento international airport: Homeland Security Secretary Janet Napolitano says travelers might soon be able to keep their kicks on during security screenings.

In news likely to soothe frazzled travelers, Homeland Security Secretary Janet Napolitano tells Politico that airline passengers might soon be able to go through airport security screening without removing their shoes. Passengers have had to remove their footwear... More

opinion brief

The end of 'naked scanners'?

Thanks to new less intrusive software, TSA security agents will no longer see revealing images of travelers. Will that silence the "invasion of privacy" outcry?

The TSA's controversial airport scanners are getting an upgrade that will render passengers' bodies as cartoon images to better preserve privacy.

The Transportation Security Administration announced last week that airport scanners will no longer show images of travelers' naked bodies to security officers. Instead, thanks to a software upgrade, the scanners will "auto-detect items that could pose a potential... More

opinion brief

Will Texas' 'anti-groping' bill stymie the TSA?

The Lone Star State wants to make it a crime for federal workers to inappropriately touch travelers in security pat-downs

TSA workers in Texas can now be charged with a misdemeanor - punishable with up to a year in jail - for invasive pat-downs.

Lawmakers in Texas have passed an "anti-groping" bill that would make invasive airport security pat-downs a crime. Gov. Rick Perry revived the bill — one of the potential GOP presidential candidate's top conservative priorities — in a special legislative... More

opinion brief

TSA pat-down: Was a dying woman forced to remove her adult diaper?

Jean Weber says her 95-year-old mother was subjected to an embarrassing airport security ordeal — though the TSA denies wrongdoing

The Transportation Security Administration is a favorite punching bag of frustrated travelers, but a recent incident involving a dying cancer patient has many TSA haters even more outraged than normal.

The Transportation Security Administration came in for another round of bad publicity over the weekend, when a Florida woman, Jean Weber, complained that TSA agents forced her 95-year-old wheelchair-bound mother to remove her soiled adult diaper before passing... More

Comment Print

Facebook

Twitter

Stumble

Tumblr

RSS

Newsletter

See our bad opinions
Only In America #1

A Wisconsin man jumps in front of his wife's car to stop her from voting for a Democrat — and more in our collection of strange revelations about the nation

Can you guess what's really going on in these bizarre photos?

Get The Week iPad app
Get The Week iPad app