Kanye West's 'painful' fashion debut

The vainglorious musician unveils his new fashion collection in Paris — and many critics urge him not to quit his day job

Best Opinion:  Guardian, WSJ, Huff. Post

Saturday night during Paris Fashion Week, Kanye West followed in the illustrious footsteps of celebs-turned-designers Lindsay Lohan, the Olsen Twins, and Victoria Beckham by debuting his first fashion collection. West's dramatic womenswear line for Spring/Summer 2012 featured luxurious materials, streamlined silhouettes, and an abundance of zippers and bare skin. Not surprisingly, it polarized critics. Was Kanye's extravagant runway show promising, or a "painful" sign that the hip hop impresario should stick to music?

This would have been impressive without Kanye's ego: For a debut collection it was "quite good," says Jess Cartner-Morley at Britain's Guardian. Indeed, it reminded me of Stella McCartney's early work. Too bad it was unveiled with so much pomp and ego in a stately library transformed into an ultraviolet light box. Such an immodest presentation puts Kanye on the same level as fashion's seasoned veterans, and his gaping necklines and imperfect fits just don't compare. "If Kanye is serious about fashion, he needs to dial the circus down a little."
"Is there room at Paris fashion week for Kanye West's ego?"

It was downright hideous: "Heavy beading — including one breastplate of a top — recalled the Flintstones," while "strips of crocodile hung without reason from a leather skirt," says Christina Binkley in The Wall Street Journal. A "very large and furry fur backpack" seemed unseasonably strange for a spring/summer collection. All the opulence of Kanye's luxury materials "can't blind people to a lack of creative marksmanship." Kanye should remember that it takes "years of study and practice… to create Azzedine Alaia or Alexander McQueen."
"Good thing Kanye West has a day job"

He should stick to music: Kanye is a "musical and lyrical genius," says Malcolm Harris at The Huffington Post, but the "poorly constructed dress made of cut bands, a fur throw rug, and an asymmetrical jacket" that Kanye sent down the runway didn't demonstrate much talent for fashion design. Sadly, Kanye showed "a tone-deaf collection, absent of any voice, vision or direction." I hope he won't show another collection "until it is at the level of [his] musical masterpieces College Drop Out, Late Registration or My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy."
"Open letter to musician Kanye West: Kanye, please stop!"

 

'Otis': Kanye West and Jay-Z's 'crazy-soulful' new single

The reigning kings of hip-hop tease another track from their upcoming album Watch the Throne. Does "Otis" make the grade?

The audio: After numerous delays and teases, the collaborative album Watch the Thrones from rap giants Kanye West and Jay-Z will  be released officially Aug. 2. With buzz for the album reaching cacophonous levels — even after a mixed response to... More

Why are critics turning on Kanye West?

His new album was the consensus pick as the best of 2010. But now some critics are finding fault with West's chart-topping success

Kanye West's album My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy delighted music critics when it came out in November. The fifth release from the always-controversial rapper wowed everyone from new-media tastemakers (Pitchfork gave the album a rare 10.0 rating) to old-guard... More

Kanye's 'disturbing' 'Monster' music video

A preview for the rapper's latest attempt at mass outrage features horror film imagery and lots of dead girls in lingerie

The video: Kanye West "sells his albums based on the aggregate of controversy and buzz," his fellow musician and frequent collaborator John Legend has said. West gave a fresh demonstration this week with the release of a 30-second video clip that provoked an outpouring... More

Kanye's new album: An 'instant greatest hits'

The mercurial rapper's latest record, 'My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy,' is getting rave reviews across the board. What's fueling the buzz?

With the media circus surrounding Kanye West — his cameo role in President's Bush's memoir tour, a flipout at Matt Lauer, and a string of seemingly unhinged Twitter musings — the rapper's creative output has taken a backseat to his unpredictable antics... More

Should Kanye have apologized to Bush?

The rapper has expressed remorse for saying, in 2005, that then-President George Bush "doesn't care about black people." Should he have stood by the remark?

In a recent "Today" show interview, Kanye West expressed remorse for his now-infamous 2005 remark that "George Bush doesn't care about black people" in regard to the then-president's handling of Hurricane Katrina. Bush has called that moment an "all-time low.... More