Will a disastrous Oscars ruin James Franco's career?

Some wonder if the young actor can recover from his epic Oscar-hosting fail

Best Opinion:  NY Press, Movieline, Huff. Post...

Was he stoned? Or just apathetic? Did he think he was too cool to even be there? Critics and Oscar viewers puzzled over such questions after James Franco's dismal, listless attempt to co-host the Academy Awards (with Anne Hathaway) on Sunday night. Some commentators say Franco "ruined" the Oscars. Will this public disaster derail his career?

This could be the end: Franco had declared he'd do his best at the Oscars, but if that was his best, there's "no way" his career can fully recover, says Annie Lubin at New York Press. He's beginning to seem like one of those people who's "interested in doing a mediocre job at everything." Still, "we've seen more unlikely comebacks after worse falls." He's got five movies set to come out this year — "let's hope at least one of them is decent."
"After Last Night's Oscars, is there hope for James Franco?"

I'm done with him: Franco basically "took a massive dump on roughly 37 million Americans who looked forward" to the big night, says Mike Ryan at Movieline. Now, "I'm pretty much done with him." Moving forward, he needs to "seriously reevaluate what he's doing and what it really means to accept a job — especially one like 'master of ceremonies,'" though I'm not sure I'll be there to watch.
"I am so over you, James Franco"

But the Oscars weren't his fault: Yes, this was "the worst Oscar telecast" in decades, but the fault lies with the writers, says Scott Mendelson at The Huffington Post. Franco was working with "awkward... poorly-scripted banter," so it's understandable he checked out. Plus, "not every actor can be an Oscar host." Whatever he chooses to do next after this experience, he "probably has material for another documentary or short play or Ph.D thesis or interpretive dance."
"Oscar 2011: Don't blame James Franco and Anne Hathaway, blame the writers"

He'll survive this: Franco has become an actor whose primary vocation is deconstructing his own celebrity, says Kyle Buchanan at New York. But "Hollywood is more forgiving than you might think to actors who indulge in long-term self-satirization" (see Joaquin Phoenix). While the general public may have soured on him, top directors are still likely to seek him out.
"James Franco: Now what?"

 

James Franco's Oscar fail: 5 theories

By nearly all accounts, the likable actor bombed in his Oscar co-hosting gig. What went wrong?

Some are calling this year's Academy Awards the "worst Oscars ever," and much of the blame is falling on co-host James Franco, who didn't exactly exert himself to make the show memorable. What led Franco, a respected actor and an Oscar nominee himself, to fail... More

Is Anne Hathaway funny enough to host the Oscars?

A series of promotional videos feature the starlet dancing, bantering, and mugging for the camera. Awkward or hilarious?

This week, a series of fresh promo videos featuring Oscar co-hosts Anne Hathaway and James Franco hit the internet, inspiring mixed reactions. In one clip, Hathaway boogies zanily in a fake outtakes reel. (Watch the video below.) In another, Hathaway plays an Eva... More

Banksy vs. the Oscars: Should nominees wear disguises?

The Oscar-nominated documentary director and street artist wants to wear a disguise to the awards show to preserve his anonymity — but the Academy is nervous

The Best Documentary category continues to be one of the less predictable Oscar races. There is no clear frontrunner nominee, and if Exit Through the Gift Shop wins, it's unclear who will accept the award. The film's director, Banksy, a street-artist who fiercely... More

Street art in L.A.: Banksy's guerilla Oscar campaign?

Images that look like those of the anonymous Oscar-nominated street artist are popping up around Los Angeles — and fueling speculation

The image: Exit Through the Gift Shop, the film from the anonymous street artist known as Banksy, is a major contender in what is, oddly enough, shaping up to be one of this year's most exciting Oscar races: Best Documentary. Now, with the awards just over a week... More

Melissa Leo's 'rogue' Oscar campaign

The Best Supporting Actress frontrunner has taken out ads at her own expense to win over Oscar voters. Will the immodest move pay off or backfire?

The image: Oscar-nominated actress Melissa Leo has gone "rogue." Not content to let the studio marketing department push her supporting actress work in The Fighter on Academy Awards voters, and frustrated that she wasn't able to land magazine covers like a younger... More