The Sarah Palin documentary: 'Bad propaganda'?

The much-anticipated Mama Grizzly movie hits theaters — and critics are growling  

Best Opinion:  Atlantic, TIME, Hollywood Reporter

Harry Potter isn't the only big-name movie hitting theaters this weekend. At long last, the two-hour Sarah Palin documentary, The Undefeated, is out — at least in Atlanta, Dallas, Denver, Houston, Indianapolis, Kansas City, Oklahoma City, Orange County, Calif., Orlando, and Phoenix. Sorry, New York, Los Angeles, and Chicago — you'll have to wait. No one was expecting a Tea Party Citizen Kane from conservative filmmaker Stephen Bannon, but all the same, critics (who've so far given the movie a 0 percent favorability rating on Rotten Tomatoes) are deriding the film, not just for being pro-Palin propaganda, but for being "bad propaganda." How foul is it?

It's amateurishly bad: The Palin documentary "makes no pretense of being anything more than a full-length commercial endorsement of her character and accomplishments," says Robert Levin at The Atlantic. It's just too bad the director, conservative Stephen Bannon, isn't a better filmmaker. He beats every talking point to a pulp, "with earsplitting soundtrack flourishes, aggressive montage, and an overall state of high anxiety." The film's biggest problem isn't its "hagiographic leanings." It's the "simple fact that its director needs to go back to film school."
"Sarah Palin's The Undefeated: Bad propaganda, worse filmmaking"

And quite boring: "The first hour of The Undefeated, scrupulously attentive to Palin's rise through state politics, is pretty rough going, a turgid primer in Alaska's pipeline management and oil, gas and, yes, milk subsidies," says Richard Corliss at TIME. What could have been a compelling film about Palin's place in the political landscape, and the establishment's handling of her, is marred by Bannon's clumsy, yawn-inducing attempt at propaganda. The movie might lead "even the most ardent conservatives to emulate their idol's tenure as governor and walk out halfway through."
"The Undefeated: Her holiness Sarah Palin"

And very thin on new material: This film is little more than "a string of encomiums against a backdrop of frantically edited archival material," says Todd McCarthy at The Hollywood Reporter. Palin wasn't even interviewed for the documentary, though some excerpts from her audio book are featured. There's no worthwhile analysis here, "nothing about her personal life, international inexperience, or interview gaffes." It's essentially a redundant, two-hour film "stitched together with a thousand sound bites" and a grating musical score.
"The Undefeated: Film review"

see 30 comments

Sarah Palin vs. the media

Mama Grizzly is playing a "cat-and-mouse game" with the press, ducking them at every turn and leaving reporters "confused and scrambling." Is she damaging her 2012 hopes?

Unconventional. Unorthodox. A rule-breaker. Sarah Palin is once again proving she's all those things with her "One Nation" bus tour of historic sites along the East Coast. The unusual trip has "left reporters confused and scrambling," says Chris Cillizza in The... More

Was Sarah Palin's reality TV show government-subsidized?

Critics crow over the revelation that "Sarah Palin's Alaska" took advantage of state tax credits that Palin herself created

Self-styled Tea Party queen Sarah Palin is probably the last person you'd expect to line up for a government handout. But it has emerged that her reality TV show, "Sarah Palin's Alaska," received a $1.2 million subsidy from the state, covering almost a third of... More

Is Julianne Moore the right choice to play Sarah Palin?

HBO casts the flame-haired actress as America's most famous (and most pilloried) conservative. Was Tina Fey not available?

HBO and director Jay Roach (Meet the Parents, Recount) are bringing the gossipy 2008 campaign book Game Change: Obama and the Clintons, McCain and Palin, and the Race of a Lifetime to the small screen, and they've already made the most-anticipated casting decision... More

Bill O'Reilly grills Sarah Palin: Who won?

The Alaskan conservative gets a little testy when Fox News' interrupter-in-chief asks her some tough questions about entitlement reform

The video: Fox News host Bill O'Reilly had Sarah Palin on his show Friday night to discuss entitlement reform, and he wouldn't take vague generalities for an answer. O'Reilly repeatedly pressed Palin for specifics on how she would tackle Social Security, Medicaid... More

When Sarah Palin met Kate Gosselin

Last night on "Sarah Palin's Alaska," the Mama Grizzly camped out with the infamous mother of eight and her kids — in a set-up designed to highlight the two women's contrasts

The video: Last night, in what's being called "a TLC match made in heaven, or hell," the worlds of two of the channel's biggest reality stars collided. For an episode of "Sarah Palin's Alaska," the former governor took Kate Gosselin and her "Kate Plus 8" brood... More