Is Titanic worth seeing again in 3D?

James Cameron shelled out a reported $18 million to add a third dimension to his 1998 blockbuster and, according to some critics, it was worth every penny

Best Opinion:  NY Post, Wash. Post, Toronto Star

Fifteen years after Titanic smashed box office records and swept the Academy Awards with 11 wins, director James Cameron's blockbuster starring Leonardo DiCaprio and Kate Winslet is heading back to theaters — this time in 3D. Cameron, who has blasted other filmmakers for their shoddy attempts to convert 2D films to 3D, spent 60 weeks and $18 million trying to get the process right for Wednesday's release of Titanic 3D, timed to coincide with the 100th anniversary of the real-life disaster. The burning question: How many people have yet to see a movie that took in $1.8 billion during its first theatrical run and has become ubiquitous on cable movie channels? And for everyone else, is the new look worth the ticket price?

It's spectacular: The 3D conversion, executed with obvious care and a great deal of subtlety by Cameron, makes "a great film even greater," says Lou Lumenick at The New York Post. The mammoth ship looks all the more impressive, the exhilarating disaster scenes all the more "jaw-dropping," and the scene in which Jack rescues Kate from a suicide attempt becomes more "terrifying and intimately romantic" in 3D. The transformation "more than justifies another big-screen voyage."
"Watch: Titanic a must-see in 3D"

It's needless: Titanic 3D serves as the poster film for "how unnecessary such technological gimmicks are when you have a perfectly good original in the first place," says Ann Hornaday at The Washington Post. The 3D conversion doesn't look bad, but the added visual depth fails to enhance the film's "humanism and spectacle." Occasionally, the 3D "creates distance where there should be intimacy," or distractingly gives background extras a visual weight equal to the scene's main players. The 3D release only serves to remind us that this thrilling, bravura film "has had the right dimensions all along."
"Titanic 3D"

It changes the future of 3D: Films converted from 2D to 3D, with the promise that "immersive" effects will draw audiences into a scene the way "flat" images can't, have generally disappointed, says Peter Howell at The Toronto Star. Titanic 3D, however, "shows how the ambition can be realized if the will and skill are there." Every scene is sharper and brighter. Some shots, like the swirling camera pan on the grand staircase, are "now so intense as to almost induce vertigo." Finally, we're seeing the artistic value of a 3D conversion, which should inspire more filmmakers to follow in Cameron's footsteps. 
"Titanic 3D review: The ship still sinks — but 3D finally floats"

 

Is Star Wars: Episode I any better in 3D?

George Lucas is betting that a costly 3D conversion will convince audiences to endure the offensive Jar Jar Binks and tiresome taxation debates anew

Can a 3D revamp make Star Wars: Episode 1 — The Phantom Menace watchable? It's fair to say that the 1999 prequel is the least beloved of the six-film Star Wars saga. When it premiered 13 years ago, critics blasted its narrative obsession with trade taxation... More

Werner Herzog's 'Cave of Forgotten Dreams': A new dimension for 3D?

Critics are saying the arty German director's "enveloping" new documentary makes better use of 3D than by-the-numbers blockbuster fare

In movieland, the third dimension is typically the province of big budget animated flicks and franchise fare. But, this weekend, theatres are handing out the special glasses for decidedly artier fare: Werner Herzog's documentary about Paleolithic cave paintings... More

Wimbledon in 3D: Will audiences watch tennis in theaters?

Sony plans to beam the prestigious tournament's finals to cinemas equipped for high-definition 3D — whether or not anyone shows up

The finals of this summer's Wimbledon tennis championship will be filmed in high-definition 3D and screened live, as the matches unfold, in 3D-equipped cinemas around the world. The streaming video, produced by Sony and the All England Lawn Tennis Club, will also... More

Can 3D save 'Star Wars: The Phantom Menace'?

The critically panned 1999 prequel will be the first "Star Wars" film to get a third dimension. Why bother, say some commentators

For many fans, the Star Wars prequels, from The Phantom Menace (1999) to The Clone Wars (2008), are a cruel farce — a woodenly acted, highly profitable mockery of the beloved three original films. But Star Wars creator George Lucas has no intention of sweeping... More

Penthouse 3D: Will Europe embrace a new dimension of porn?

Penthouse has rolled out the world's first 3D adult channel. It's certainly a technological breakthrough, but is it a good idea?

Penthouse is adding a new dimension to its porn by launching the world's first 3D adult television channel. On Tuesday, Penthouse 3D joined the lineup of Europe's Astra satellite network. Television sets equipped with 3D technology still have not gained widespread... More