RSS
Driving while Hispanic?
In Dallas, police officers have been ticketing drivers for not being able to speak English. Racism or an innocent error?
S

ince 2007, police officers in Dallas have issued dozens of traffic tickets to drivers who don’t speak English. All but one of the motorists cited were Hispanic. The police department has acknowledged it erred—that, in fact, no laws were violated—and is investigating the incidents. But what does the pattern mean?

The ticketing may have been motivated by racism: “Some will call this an honest mistake,” says Ruben Navarrette Jr. in the San Jose Mercury News. But doing so involves overlooking the fact that the “mistake occurred at least 38 times” at the hands of 20 separate police officers. “Is this racism—maybe a new strain of that ugly virus?” If not, “what should we call it? Linguistic profiling?"
"'Crime' in Dallas"

Local cops shouldnt do immigration enforcement: Whatever the reason these particular tickets were given, the explanation is “likely to be highly embarrassing to the Dallas authorities,” says The New York Times in an editorial. But the incidents are merely part of a broader national debate over what role local authorities should play in immigration enforcement—and proof that outsourcing the task to local police tends to yield poor results.
"Driving without English"

Law or no law, drivers who can’t read English are dangerous: Perhaps drivers should be able to demonstarate a basic proficiency in English, says Bryan McAffee in Right Juris. "There are safety signs, traffic signs, and other situations where having a command of the English language might make a whole lot of sense. The problem is you have to make it apply to everyone."
"Dallas police issue tickets for not speaking English"

EDITORS' PICKS

THE WEEK'S AUDIOPHILE PODCASTS: LISTEN SMARTER

Subscribe to the Week