President Obama invoked Vietnam four times in his Afghanistan “surge” speech at West Point on Tuesday, arguing that the two wars are different, and that “we have not lost” in Afghanistan. But pundits and analysts on both sides of the political spectrum aren’t so sure Afghanistan isn’t another quagmire. Is Obama sending 30,000 more troops to a war we’ve already lost? (Watch Sen. John McCain express support for Obama's troop escalation)
Obama can’t win this: Obama’s faith in the Afghanistan war won’t be enough to salvage it, says Richard Cohen in The Washington Post. Just like "Korea defeated Truman, Vietnam doomed Johnson, and Iraq put a dunce cap on Bush," Obama can’t "prevail in Afghanistan—not with another 30,000 troops," and not in 18 months, especially given the "isolationist stupor" our war-weary nation is slipping into.
"A novel way to argue for war"
Armchair quarterbacking is useless: Look, "I may believe Afghanistan to be an unwinnable quagmire that only cost lives and dollars with short results," says blogger Tom Watson, but I’m not the president. Obama is, "and now it’s his war." And we’d better hope he’s picked the right course, because "American interests and lives" are still in danger from the Afghanistan-Pakistan region.
Why do we need to "win"? Count me "ready to live with a little less security and a little-less-perfect Afghanistan," says Thomas Friedman in The New York Times. Even if we had the money, we were never going to "make Afghanistan into Norway." And we don’t have the money, "given our need for nation-building at home right now."
"This I believe"
Obama’s redefining success: "Obama’s strategy will not transform Afghanistan" from the "desperately poor, mainly illiterate, deeply traditional, xenophobic, and backward place" the Soviets invaded, then retreated from, says Tim Rutten in the Los Angeles Times, but "it may someday make that country safe enough to leave." And if that’s how we define success, Obama may—eventually—succeed.
"The reality of Afghanistan"
THE WEEK'S AUDIOPHILE PODCASTS: LISTEN SMARTER
- The Obama era is over. The presidency continues.
- America created the Islamic State of Iraq and Syria? Meet the ISIS 'truthers'
- What is Molly? Everything you need to know about the party drug
- What would a U.S.-Russia war look like?
- Russia's giant spy ship was a high-tech disaster waiting to happen
- How American businessmen are ruining American business — and the U.S. economy
- The constant struggle of running a family farm in 21st century America
- How Harry Houdini escaped death
- How to stop misogynists from terrorizing the world of gamers
- 10 things you need to know today: September 2, 2014
Subscribe to the Week