RSS
The Tea Party and the Hutaree: Activism vs. Extremism?
Debate is brewing over attempts to draw parallels between Tea Partiers and the "Christian" militia group arrested in Michigan
An image from the now-defunct Hutaree website.
An image from the now-defunct Hutaree website.
Hutaree.com
N

ine members of the "Hutaree," a Michigan-based militia group who describe themselves as "Christian warriors," have been indicted on weapons and conspiracy charges after a weekend of FBI raids. (See: "Who are the Hutaree?") The arrests are provoking debate about where to draw the line between conservative activists — such as Tea Party members — and right-wing extremists who brazenly plot to use violence against the government:

You can't tar both groups with the same brush: No matter what "our opinion leaders" think, says Tom Smith at The Right Coast, there is a distinction between Americans who literally believe the "Illuminati [is] running the world" and voters who aren't "wild about health care." Even if the media fails to understand that these militia members are "looney toons," not "tea baggers," let's hope the FBI does.
"Oh great"

Tea Partiers may dismiss the connection, but there's a serious overlap: "Mainstream purveyors of incendiary far-right rhetoric" may say that "crazies" like the Hutaree don't come from their ranks, says Eugene Robinson in the Washington Post. But that's debatable. Both Tea Party protests and militia violence schemes are "incited" by the same source: "The vitriolic, anti-government hate speech that is spewed on talk radio every day."
"The Hutaree militia and the rising risk of far-right violence"


The Hutaree aren't politically engaged activists, they're cranks: Take a look at the Hutaree website, says Brian Doherty at Reason.com, and examine the "intellectual and cultural milieu" of these extremists. These people aren't political activists, they're "angry loudmouths who've fantasized too much." The courts must decide how much of a "real threat" they are (or were), but it would "surprise the hell out of me" if the Hutaree gave "much of a damn" about politics. 
"The Hutaree arrest and getting tough on terror from left and right"

EDITORS' PICKS

THE WEEK'S AUDIOPHILE PODCASTS: LISTEN SMARTER

Subscribe to the Week