RSS
Health reform repeal: Realistic GOP goal or 'reckless stunt'?
While some commentators see House Republicans' plan to push through a repeal of "ObamaCare" as smart politics, others call it delusional
Rep. Fred Upton (R-MI) says he is confident that a Republican repeal of the health reform law would pass in the House with a veto-proof majority.
Rep. Fred Upton (R-MI) says he is confident that a Republican repeal of the health reform law would pass in the House with a veto-proof majority.
Getty
R

ep. Fred Upton (R-MI), the incoming chairman of the powerful House Energy and Commerce Committee, pledged that his branch of Congress would pass a repeal of the Democrats' health reform law before President Obama's State of the Union address in late January. Upton predicted the repeal bill would pass with a veto-proof majority, pressuring the Democratic-controlled Senate to follow suit. Is there any basis for Upton's optimism — or it just wishful thinking? (Watch a Fox News discussion about the GOP's hopes)

This is just a GOP stunt: "House Republicans are doing this for show," and everybody knows it, says Steve Benen in Washington Monthly. There is zero chance the Senate will agree to this "public-relations stunt," and Obama's veto power seals its failure. Besides, would Republicans really want their first big act upon taking control of the House to involve "taking away health care coverage for millions" and "making seniors pay more for prescription drugs"?
"Going through the motions on repeal"

Republicans have a shot at partial repeal: Upton's assertion that he has a veto-proof majority "is actually laughable," says Doug Mataconis in Outside the Beltway, since it means 42 House Democrats will have to side with him. But Obama and the Democrats won't be laughing if Republicans give up on their "Hail Mary Pass" of achieving complete repeal and focus instead on a piece-by-piece attack to undo certain "onerous and unnecessary" provisions. The GOP could win "a few victories" that way.
"House will take up repeal of ObamaCare..."

Democrats should welcome this attack: "Turn 'em loose, I say," says Taylor Marsh in her blog. The health care overhaul "is a bad bill," but it is a step in the right direction, and Republicans have no idea how to replace it. So "Democrats should clear the way and let conservatives have the floor" — "when your adversary is intent on making a fool of himself, don't get in his way."
"Conservatives first attack: 'ObamaCare'"

EDITORS' PICKS

THE WEEK'S AUDIOPHILE PODCASTS: LISTEN SMARTER

Subscribe to the Week