Telecom giant AT&T announced plans over the weekend to buy T-Mobile, its smaller rival, for $39 billion in cash and stock. The surprise deal is expected to close next year, if government regulators approve it, and will effectively reduce the number of national cellphone carriers from four to three — AT&T, Verizon and Sprint. Who stands to win from this enormous merger, and who will lose out?
"Probably the most surprising winner... is AT&T," says Scott Moritz at The Street. You might expect such a costly acquisition to scare off those investors who view it as "dilutive and risky," but the market is "cheering the moxie of a big wireless land grab." AT&T shares were already up 3 percent in early trading on Monday.
The positives for T-Mobile's German parent company, says Archibald Preuschat at The Wall Street Journal, include a board seat at AT&T and 8 percent of the company. Even better, the $25 billion in cash it's pocketing will pay off a significant amount of its debt. Even if regulators shut the deal down, it will still get a "$3 billion break fee." The European giant is "the darling of investors right now."
The Dow Jones Industrial Average surged this morning on news of AT&T's acquisition, says CNBC.com. It gained more than 190 points in morning trading — welcome news after a week in which the Japanese crisis and lower-than-expected existing home sales pummeled the Dow. "All key S&P 500 sectors gained, led by energy, technology and industrials."
The Federal Communications Commission has gained leverage, says former FCC chief counsel Bruce Gottlieb at The Atlantic. Though congressional Democrats and consumer groups are already crying foul about the merger, "any company with a major transaction before the government suddenly gets a lot more cooperative on every other issue." So, if the FCC plays its cards right, it could force AT&T to expand its 4G coverage nationwide.
"Sprint is clearly seen as the big loser here," says Eric Savitz at Forbes. Sprint had attempted to buy T-Mobile itself, but was rebuffed. Now, its stock has slumped 15 percent in morning trading, and it faces the prospect of being a distant third in the cellphone market for the foreseeable future, a "nightmare scenario."
T-Mobile has long been a "distinct alternative" to AT&T, says Kent German at CNET. It "excelled at customer service, it delivered on value, and it never failed to keep its phones interesting," even if it did not offer the Apple iPhone. Will AT&T match T-Mobile's customer service and retain its "aggressive prepaid plan pricing"? Given AT&T's record, "I'm not hopeful." And T-Mobile customers hoping to finally get their hands on an iPhone will reportedly have to wait at least a year.
"Don't think this deal won't affect you if you aren't a T-Mobile customer," says Brett Arends at MarketWatch. The loss of a fourth player in the cellphone market means less choice, which means less power for the consumer. AT&T's Soviet-style dominance was large enough already. "After this deal, the three players left will be able to sit back, take it easy, and carve up the hapless consumer."
The merger will give AT&T roughly 130 million total customers, says Julie Gerstein at New York. "But it'll likely come at the expense of thousands of jobs." The telecom behemoth employs 267,000 people, while T-Mobile employs just 38,000. How many of those jobs will disappear as the merger goes through?
Nokia, Sony Ericsson, and other device manufacturers... except Apple
"Fewer national carriers means fewer large companies to distribute [manufacturers'] wares," says Avram Piltch at Laptop Magazine. Together, AT&T and T-Mobile offer nearly 50 smartphones. "Expect that number to be cut in half," bad news for companies like Nokia and Sony Ericsson who are trying to grow market share. It's better news, though, for Apple, which will see less competition from T-Mobile's range of smartphones and tablets.
THE WEEK'S AUDIOPHILE PODCASTS: LISTEN SMARTER
- How Israel's hawks intimidated and silenced the last remnants of the anti-war left
- Why you should stop believing in evolution
- The secret to handling pressure like astronauts, Navy SEALs, and samurai
- Why China thinks it could defeat the U.S. in battle
- Welcome to the age of ambivalent feminism
- Why your employer should clean your house and do your laundry
- What you need to know before you support the police in Ferguson
- How the West produces jihadi tourists
- What would a U.S.-Russia war look like?
Subscribe to the Week