RSS
'Man Down': Is Rihanna's revenge video too violent?
The singer — and high-profile victim of abuse — sparks an angry backlash with a scene in which she shoots a rapist
 
Within the first 30 seconds of Rihanna's new video "Man Down," the pop star shoots a man dead for raping her: A pro-murder message, say her critics; artistic expression, counters Rihanna.
Within the first 30 seconds of Rihanna's new video "Man Down," the pop star shoots a man dead for raping her: A pro-murder message, say her critics; artistic expression, counters Rihanna.
YouTube

The video: Rihanna is no stranger to controversy, but the new video for her single "Man Down" has sparked what might be the angriest backlash to her music yet. In the context of the video's storyline, the Barbados native shoots a man dead for raping her. (See the video below.) Rihanna, who was physically abused by now-ex-boyfriend Chris Brown, has defended her work, tweeting: "This is the real world." The Parents Television Council, internet watchdog Enough is Enough, and the Industry Ears think tank have all demanded that BET, which premiered the video this week, yank it off the air, calling it a stunt to sell albums. "I have never witnessed such a cold, calculated execution of murder in prime time," says Paul Porter of Industry Ears. "If Chris Brown shot a woman in his new video and BET premiered it, the world would stop. Rihanna should not get a pass."

The reaction: Killing someone who hurts you doesn't make you a feminist — it makes you a murderer, says Jessica Wakeman at The Frisky. "Sorry, RiRi, but I don't think perpetuating violence is 'edgy,'" even if this is how you're processing the beating you took at the hands of Brown. I believe Rihanna, counters A.J. Hammer at CNN, when she says this is about empowering girls who have suffered like her. "She's expressing herself. It may be in a provocative way, but this is her art." Judge for yourself:

 

 

 

THE WEEK'S AUDIOPHILE PODCASTS: LISTEN SMARTER

Subscribe to the Week