RSS
India's massive, record-setting blackout: 5 talking points
About 670 million Indians — nearly 10 percent of the world's population — were left in the dark in a stinging embarrassment for the rising economic power
 
Muslim girls study by candlelight inside a religious school on the outskirts of New Delhi: An embarrasingly massive blackout puts a spotlight on India's creaky, patchwork infrastructure.
Muslim girls study by candlelight inside a religious school on the outskirts of New Delhi: An embarrasingly massive blackout puts a spotlight on India's creaky, patchwork infrastructure.
REUTERS/Parivartan Sharma

India experienced massive blackouts earlier this week, forcing some 670 million people in the northern and eastern parts of the country to go without power. "It was the largest blackout in global history in terms of the number of people affected — about 10 percent of the world population," say Simon Denyer and Rama Lakshmi at The Washington Post. Indian officials say power has now been restored across much of the country, but the government is coming under a flood of criticism for failing to update India's creaky, outdated energy infrastructure, which has long been considered an enormous obstacle to India's ambition of becoming an Asian economic powerhouse alongside China. Here, five takeaways from the world's largest-ever blackout:

1. The blackout extended from coast to coast
No area of northern India was spared, with the blackout stretching from the country's eastern border with Myanmar to its western border with Pakistan. Even though 300 million Indians don't have access to electricity even on a good day, and blackouts are so common that many businesses and homes are powered with diesel generators, the blackout was still a disaster. Traffic lights went out at intersections, causing chaos on the roads, while India's train system shuddered to a halt, leaving passengers stranded for hours. 

2. The precise cause of the blackout is in dispute…
Federal officials blame individual states for taking more than their allotted portion of electricity. State officials retort that the federal government is responsible for monitoring the system and ensuring that everything is in order. Either way, three interconnected power grids suddenly shut down. The country's electrical grid has been compared to "a whole bunch of rubber bands," meaning it's unclear which ones are stretched to the limit and could snap at any moment.

3. …But the overarching cause couldn't be clearer
"There is no mystery to the darkness in India, say Harsh Joshi and Duncan Mavin at The Wall Street Journal: The country simply doesn't produce enough energy to keep up with rising demand, forcing the government to conduct rolling blackouts throughout India to preserve electricity. "And with per capita energy consumption expected to double by 2020," says National Geographic, "India needs urgently to generate more power and deliver it more efficiently." 

4. This is a humiliation for the country
"Superpower India, RIP" read a headline in India's The Economic Times. Obviously, this crisis has "reinforced concerns that industry leaders had been raising for years," say Denyer and Lakshmi: "That the nation's horribly inefficient power sector could undermine its long-term economic ambitions." The blackout also put a spotlight on the myriad problems that have prevented the government from improving its energy sector, including the electricity subsidies used to buy votes, rampant corruption in the utility industry, and a knot of cumbersome regulations that scare away private investment.

5. India must reform
India must make bold moves if it ever wants to modernize its energy infrastructure, says Amol Sharma at The Wall Street Journal. The federal government must rein in states that draw more than their allotted share of power; raise the price of power, even if it's politically unpopular; develop its own sources of energy, like coal and nuclear; and allow more private companies to invest in the country's creaky, top-down utility sector. "India will get the lights back on," say Joshi and Mavin. "But there is no simple flick of the switch that can power up India's fortunes."

Sources: CNN, National GeographicThe New York Times (2), The Wall Street Journal (2), The Washington Post

 

THE WEEK'S AUDIOPHILE PODCASTS: LISTEN SMARTER

Subscribe to the Week