ith the "comedy gold" of the Meet the Parents movies and the political heft of the HBO dramas Recount and Game Change under his belt, says the AP's Michael Rechtshaffen, director Jay Roach "would seem to have been the ideal guy to be steering The Campaign," a new political satire about a North Carolina congressman (Will Ferrell) trying to fend off an unexpected challenge from a naive, initially inept rival (Zach Galifianakis). (Watch trailer below) But while we could all probably use a good laugh in the middle of this decidedly unfunny election season, any satire would have to work really hard to out-absurdify modern politics. Does the new Ferrell movie come up short?
The Campaign is no match for reality: There are some decent laughs in this mild goofball comedy, says Alison Willmore at Movieline. But as a satire of our "wild reality show" politics, it "feels disconcertingly and disappointingly mild." Part of the problem is Roach's decision to keep the movie's point-of-view nonpartisan, but part of it is his source material: Even the film's most savagely ridiculous mudslinging seems neither "all that far from actual, awful political attacks" nor as absurd as "an actual Herman Cain ad."
"Mild goofball laughs... no match for real-life political circus"
At least this version of politics is funny: It's true, today's attack politics are at least as "over the top" as Roach's fictional version, says David Riedel in the Santa Fe Reporter. But hey, "at least The Campaign is funny." Not only is this Ferrell's best comedic role since Anchorman's Ron Burgundy, the movie also has enough substance and heart to make it an "ultimately moral take on politics...."
"Vote LOL: The Campaign is a welcome return to form for Will Ferrell"
Relax — this is fantasy, not satire: "This isn't a film with bite — but I'm not sure it's trying to be," says Karina Longworth in the Denver Westword. It borrows enough from contemporary politics to feel vaguely relevant — like its "no-duh thesis" that "corporate-controlled candidates are, like, bad" — but by design The Campaign is "less a satire than a utopian fantasy," a "small-town fable" with a happy ending. Its fantastical solutions to our very real problems even makes the movie "almost charming — but like a third-party candidate, it's also incredibly easy to ignore."
"The Campaign is toothless but amusing"
Bottom Line: If you're a news junkie who's disgusted by this election year and is looking for incisive, relevant satire to relieve the pain, skip The Campaign. If you're just expecting laughs, give it a chance.
THE WEEK'S AUDIOPHILE PODCASTS: LISTEN SMARTER
- 31 TV shows to watch in 2014
- Why atheism doesn't have the upper hand over religion
- The world's dumbest idea: Taxing solar energy
- He said he was leaving. She ignored him.
- 14 wonderful words with no English equivalent
- Why would a young person today be religious?
- Why we can't stop procrastinating, according to science
- What would a U.S.-Russia war look like?
- What liberals get wrong about having kids
- If a nuclear bomb exploded in downtown Washington, what should you do?
Subscribe to the Week