eople who are slightly overweight may or may not live a bit longer — a controversial debate incited by a recent study — but it's pretty universally understood that being obese is bad. The morbidly overweight, though, have few appealing options: Going on extreme diets and trying to exercise away some extra pounds, a bariatric (gastric bypass) operation or other surgical intervention, or just giving up and living with the health risks, social stigma, and general discomfort. So it's good news, perhaps, that Dean Kamen, inventor of the little used but nonetheless technologically impressive Segway personal transporter, and a group of bariatric physicians have come up with what appears to be a surprisingly effective way of sucking away excess weight. Why only perhaps? Because the AspireAssist personal stomach pump looks stomach-churningly foul.
Here's how it works: Basically, it's a feeding tube in reverse. Instead of pumping life-sustaining nutrients into the stomachs of people unable to eat, the AspireAssist Aspiration Therapy System pumps food out of people who have no problem eating. Patients have a tube inserted into their stomachs then threaded out through an incision in the abdomen and capped with a poker chip–sized "Skin Port" valve. (For more detail, if you so dare, watch the video below.) Twenty minutes after eating breakfast, lunch, and dinner, the patient attaches a handheld device to the Skin Port and empties 30 percent of the contents of his or her stomach into the toilet.
Twenty minutes is enough time for your brain to be convinced that you are full, but not enough time for your stomach to digest the food, the inventors say, and that means 30 percent of the calories from your meal magically disappear. Philadelphia-based Aspire Bariatrics is still trying to get FDA approval to sell the AspireAssist in the U.S., but it has been available in parts of Europe since late 2011.
Reaction to the device has been, well, mixed: In a yearlong U.S. trial of AspireAssist, 24 obese patients lost about half of their excess weight, dropping an average of about 45 pounds. Anecdotal evidence suggests that people are happy with the stomach pump. "This is it for me," 55-year-old Mikael Cederhag of Sweden tells ABC News. After 30 years of "jumping up and down in weight," a year of using the pump rid him of 64 of his original 264 pounds, and counting. "Finally, this is a solution that allows me to get my weight down and stay that way," without permanently changing his body through gastric bypass surgery.
Even Assist Bariatric CEO Katherine Crothall admits that the idea of emptying your stomach is kind of "gross." The good news, though, says Colin Lecher at Popular Science, is that the AspireAssist "could work as a last-ditch effort to get obese people to shed some weight." The bad news? Well, where to start?
How about with a problem that Aspire already knows about: "Initial setbacks — and here's the really yucky part — have occurred because the pump struggles to break up large foods," like cauliflower, steak, pretzels, and Chinese food, says Gillian Orr at Britain's The Independent, so the tube sometimes gets clogged. There are also "significant doubts about the safety of this product," says Dr. Manny Alvarez at Fox News. Draining 30 percent of your stomach is a recipe for dehydration, irritation of the stomach lining, and depriving your organs of a third of "vital electrolytes such as sodium, potassium, and calcium."
"I'm sure it won't be long until tales of infections, leakage, lack of nutrient absorption, depression and suicide, severe hypoglycemia, extreme thiamine deficiency, anemia, osteoporosis, and all sorts of other complications" surface, just like they have with bariatric surgery, says Laura Beck at Jezebel. But this terrifying invention is also, let's face it, an automatic "bulimia machine." The Aspire Assist "is an enabling device, not a helping device," nutritionist Keith Ayoob at Albert Einstein College of Medicine tells ABC News. And as horrifying as it is, "it was only a matter of time before someone came up with" a machine that lets them "just eat and make the calories go away." The only healthy way to lose weight is to change your eating and lifestyle habits, but "once you put this in someone, they're never going to want it taken out."
Hopefully, gradual changes in diet will allow for the pump to be removed at some point, Cederhag tells ABC News, but "if I have to continue to flush my stomach every day or every other day, then so be it." People without weight problems don't understand. "I don't want to be seated at the table with an empty plate. This way I can eat together with my friends and my family, I can drink my beer or wine if I want to. And then I can just let go of 30 percent."
Still, it's hard to escape the unappetizing image of emptying partially masticated food into the toilet three times a day from a cyborg-like valve in your stomach. If that idea, or the video below, makes anyone lose their appetite, maybe there's some weight-loss value in AspireAssist even for those of us who never get near the device.
THE WEEK'S AUDIOPHILE PODCASTS: LISTEN SMARTER
- Why is American internet so slow?
- What would a U.S.-Russia war look like?
- Don't worry: World War III will almost certainly never happen
- What the collapse of the Ming Dynasty can tell us about American decline
- 4 life hacks from ancient philosophers that will make you happier
- Russia's Ukraine invasion is a moral crisis
- The Daily Show explains Hamid Karzai's 'Afghan Hustle'
- 22 TV shows to watch in 2014
- Mitt Romney, 2016 frontrunner*
- The end of academic freedom?
Subscribe to the Week