RSS

#Pontifexit

February 11, 2013, at 6:54 AM

This is why sleep is overrated. You'll miss news like, say, the resignation of a Pope! When the shock of the news wears off, we're left to wonder what this means. The last time a Pope resigned was all the way back in 1415.

Generally, when American political officials resign, a scandal is in the offing. But the former John Cardinal Ratzinger genuinely seems to be stepping down as Pontifex because he no longer believes he can do the job that he believes God has called him to do. 

There is something profound and endearing about someone elected (anointed?) to an incredibly powerful lifetime job deciding, with years still left, to walk away. That in and of itself is a powerful example to set for everyone.

I am no expert on the Church, but aside from a return to a deeply considered, theologically infused pastoral conservatism, there was not much Benedict could do in the eight years he spent as pope to mitigate the worldwide catastrophe that is the scandal of childhood sexual abuse in the church. Maybe my opinion is colored by my having watched Alex Gibney's new documentary, Mea Maxima Culpa: Sex Lies and the Catholic Church. When Ratzinger headed the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith (or, hundreds of years ago, the Inquisition), every accusation of abuse passed through his office. What was done, and what wasn't, during those years, is partly his responsibility.  

The 265th Pope is by all accounts (including his own) a "humble servant in the garden of the Lord." Unlike Pope John Paul II, he never had the chance to bond with Catholics worldwide. His tenure was too short, and there were too much turbulence: Whistleblowers in his own home, financial scandals, and the usual push and pull of the church and modernism. 

Who is next?

The college of Cardinals will feel pressure to account for the places where the Church is large and growing (Latin America and Africa), but the body seems rather immune to demography. They'll choose at the end of March. And the former John Ratzinger will certainly, in some form, make known his preference, even though he will not take part in the conclave.

EDITORS' PICKS

THE WEEK'S AUDIOPHILE PODCASTS: LISTEN SMARTER

Facebook

Twitter

RSS

Subscribe to the Week