The Vatican on Friday jumped to the defense of the Catholic Church's new leader, Pope Francis, to counter critics who say he didn't speak out enough during the Dirty War that divided his home country, Argentina, from 1976 to 1983. Vatican spokesman Federico Lombardi said the accusations against the pope — the former Archbishop of Buenos Aires, Jorge Mario Bergoglio — are baseless smears being used by "anti-clerical left-wing elements" to attack the church. "There has never been a credible, concrete accusation against him," Lombardi said. What, exactly, do the pope's critics claim he did — or didn't do?
First off: What was the Dirty War?
It was a dark period in Argentina's history, when, under a military junta, the South American country's armed forces kidnapped or killed tens of thousands of people — estimates of the death toll range from 9,000 to 30,000. Many victims were held in secret for months, tortured, then killed, their bodies never found. The country's military leaders said they were protecting the nation against "subversive elements." The official name for the campaign was Process of National Reorganization, but most people refer to it as the Dirty War.
Why criticize the church for the military's abuses?
Critics of Argentina's Catholic Church leaders from that era say that they, like the hierarchy in Spain during its civil war, were disturbingly close to the junta's anti-communist "witch hunt," says Jon Lee Anderson at The New Yorker. One of Bergoglio's predecessors in his Buenos Aires post, Archbishop Juan Carlos Aramburu, "openly sided with the military's stated need for a purge, in which freethinking priests and nuns were also killed," Anderson says. Some military chaplains allegedly blessed drugged and unconscious guerrilla suspects before they were loaded onto planes and dropped to their deaths. Mostly, though, critics complain that the Church simply remained mute in the face of the repression.
What does this have to do with Pope Francis?
At the time of the Dirty War, Bergoglio was Argentina's provincial, or superior, of the Jesuits, an order that has produced some of Latin America's most socially liberal clerics. A few priests and bishops have since claimed that Bergoglio singled out two leftist priests, depriving them of the church's protection and clearing the way for the military to arrest them. "He portrays himself as popular, almost revolutionary, a man who goes into the ghettos," Argentine journalist Horacio Verbitsky, author of a book on the period called The Silence, tells The Washington Post. "But when the military came to power, he did not protect his own." Bergoglio denies the accusation, noting that nobody ever produced any evidence to back it up, and saying that he personally, quietly, lobbied two members of the junta on behalf of the priests, who were released after five months.
So are the allegations unfair?
Most Argentines recognize "that if Bergoglio had been an active critic of the regime, he would almost certainly not have lived to become pope," says Uki Goni at TIME. "Other churchmen at the time were quickly murdered by the country's merciless generals." A lawyer once tried to open a legal case against Bergoglio in connection with the priests' kidnapping, but it failed for lack of evidence. Now that Bergoglio is Pope Francis, it's important to examine "his record and recollections of nearly 40 years ago," says Eugene Robinson at The Washington Post, "not so much because of what he did or did not do but because of what lessons he did or did not learn." He didn't collaborate or even approve of what the military did, "but by his own admission, he didn't try to change the world. Now he has more than the duty to lead 1.2 billion Catholics. He also has a chance to atone."
Sources: BBC News, The Los Angeles Times, The New Yorker, TIME, The Washington Post (2)
THE WEEK'S AUDIOPHILE PODCASTS: LISTEN SMARTER
- How to be the most productive person in your office — and still get home by 5:30 p.m.
- Christians have no moral rationale for spanking their children
- How our botched understanding of 'science' ruins everything
- 43 TV shows to watch in 2014
- 4 simple steaks you can cook in a pan
- 10 things you need to know today: September 23, 2014
- 6 things the happiest families all have in common
- The science of sex: 4 harsh truths about dating and mating
- Should you hope to die at 75? Absolutely not.
- Does solar energy have a battery problem?
Subscribe to the Week