San Francisco city attorney Dennis Herrera is suing Monster Beverage for allegedly marketing dangerous, densely caffeinated drinks to kids and teens. That move comes just one week after Monster sued Herrera for demanding the company reduce its energy drinks' caffeine content and stop marketing to children. Herrera says excessive consumption of these caffeine-heavy drinks can lead to cardiac arrest, elevated blood pressure, and seizures. And they're targeted at the young, he says.
The Monster brand is marketed to children and teenagers, the lawsuit said, through sponsorship of youth sports tournaments, profiles of young consumers on its Monster Army websites and promotion of a lifestyle involving extreme sports, music, gaming, military themes and the scantily clad Monster Girls.
Herrera also accused Monster of urging excessive consumption of its drinks, telling customers to "pound down" and "chug down" the products. [Los Angeles Times]
Monster, of course, is fighting back. The company says Herrera is "motivated by publicity rather than science," calls his claims "demonstrably false," and promises "to vigorously defend against this action."
The energy drink industry has enjoyed almost a decade of hyperactive growth. Sales ballooned 240 percent between 2004 and 2009, and have risen steadily since, with total sales of energy drinks and shots reaching over $12.5 billion in 2012. Market researcher Packaged Facts predicts the industry could be worth $21.5 billion by 2017.
Within this thriving industry, Monster is the biggest fish, with a market capitalization of nearly $10 billion. And Monster's share price jumped an impressive 12.5 percent in April.
Could this marketing-to-youngsters controversy put the brakes on Monster's surging growth? The allegations are certainly stacking up. The family of a 14 year-old Maryland girl is suing Monster, claiming their daughter died of cardiac arrhythmia after drinking a 24-ounce can of Monster that contained some 240 milligrams of caffeine — far more than the recommended maximum for teens. And as the New York Times reported in October, five similar accusations have arisen in the last three years.
In the Maryland case, Monster says that because no blood work was performed, the family has no way of proving their daughter died of caffeine toxicity, says the Washington Post. And the company stands by its current warning labels, which recommend a limit of one drink every four hours, and no more than three per day. Monster also insists that its drinks are not recommend for children (anyone under 12), pregnant women, or people who are "sensitive to caffeine."
But even if Monster manages to swat down Herrera's accusations, it looks like other energy drink foes will be waiting in the wings. Last summer, New York subpoenaed energy drink makers, including Monster, over their marketing techniques. And the FDA recently announced plans to investigate the effects caffeinated food products have on children and adolescents. From an FDA statement:
One pack of [caffeinated] gum is like having four cups of coffee in your pocket. Caffeine is even being added to jelly beans, marshmallows, sunflower seeds and other snacks for its stimulant effect.
Meanwhile, "energy drinks" with caffeine are being aggressively marketed, including to young people. An instant oatmeal on the market boasts that one serving has as much caffeine as a cup of coffee, and then there are similar products, such as a so-called "wired" waffle and "wired" syrup with added caffeine.
The proliferation of these products in the marketplace is very disturbing to us. [FDA]
THE WEEK'S AUDIOPHILE PODCASTS: LISTEN SMARTER
- 7 things the world's happiest people do every day
- The biggest lesson Obama failed to learn from Bush
- 7 grammar rules you really should pay attention to
- Why are so many parents being arrested?
- Israel has only two choices: Eliminate the Palestinians or make peace
- What I learned from totally unplugging and shutting up for three days
- 9 things you probably didn't know about the moon
- Why America is duty bound to help Iraqi Christians
- 10 burning questions you've always wanted to ask about investing
- What these custom, 3D-printed earphones say about the future of consumer technology
Subscribe to the Week