Last week, Overstock sparked a price war with Amazon that sent book prices tumbling by 50 to 65 percent on both sites.
In a press release, Overstock announced that it had cut book prices on "hundreds of thousands of titles" to "at least 10-percent below Amazon.com's prices."
Amazon, which famously doesn't give a dang about profits, swung back in predictable form: Without even acknowledging Overstock, it slashed prices even lower, nullifying its competitor's promise to customers. Then this week, it upped the stakes, offering a "Fall Books" promotion that sliced prices on upcoming hardcover titles that haven't even hit shelves.
Hardcovers on Amazon are going for less than their Kindle versions, and even top-selling titles are selling for dirt cheap. Gillian Flynn’s Gone Girl dropped to below $9 on both sites, compared to a list price of $25.
So who gets bloodied in this kind of price battle? Not Amazon, which is used to selling at a loss to push out competition. Buzzfeed's Andy Meek says the ultimate victims will be authors and small book-sellers. "Price wars end. They always do. They only question now is how many casualties — in the form of lost revenue for authors, or closed independent retailers — will this one claim," he says.
Matt Yglesias at Slate, however, says the price war is "great for authors":
Authors are paid by publishers, who hand out advances and royalty checks. The royalties are based on a percentage of publishers' gross revenues so the retail price of the books sold doesn't mean authors get less money. If anything, retailer discounting is good for authors and publishers because it boosts book sales. [Slate]
But what happens in the long run, when customers get used to low, low book prices? Kevin Drum at Mother Jones thinks "there's a fairly straightforward way that this could be bad for authors":
But what happens when Amazon drives everyone else out of business and there's no one left but Amazon selling books? One possibility is that prices go back up to their old level. Another is that consumers have become so accustomed to price-war pricing that they just won't pay more. Amazon, however, will no longer be willing to lose money on books, so it will demand lower wholesale prices from publishers. The publishers will have little choice but to agree, and authors will get squeezed.[Mother Jones]
Meanwhile, Dennis Johnson, cofounder of Melville Press, an independent publishing company in Brooklyn, New York, told The Verge it's small publishers and, ultimately, readers who will suffer.
[T]he price war is "particularly dangerous for little publishers like [Melville], because that kind of constant discounting devalues the product, and eventually, you have to bring your prices in line." Johnson said he fears a future where Amazon controls most publishing and where, as a consequence, people aren't exposed to smaller, more avant-garde titles like the kind his company offers. [The Verge]
So pretty much everyone loses — except Amazon, of course.
THE WEEK'S AUDIOPHILE PODCASTS: LISTEN SMARTER
- The big, gaping hole in the liberal policy arsenal
- Here's the schedule very successful people follow every day
- 7 grammar rules you really should pay attention to
- The militarization of America’s police
- Why you should really take a nap this afternoon, according to science
- What would a U.S.-Russia war look like?
- Why you shouldn't eat dog. Not even once.
- A gay Mormon's complicated journey
- Are there too many good shows on television?
- 7 things the world's happiest people do every day
Subscribe to the Week