Steven Rhodes spent the last five years in the Marines. His time there up, he returned to his native Tennessee this year to enroll in college and, he hoped, earn a spot on the football team.
One problem: The NCAA's byzantine rules wouldn't let him.
Rhodes, a 24-year-old freshman at Middle Tennessee State University and former sergeant in the Marine Corps, won a spot on the team as a walk-on. But as the Murfreesboro Daily News Journal first reported in an exhaustive profile Sunday, the NCAA barred him from competing this year because he played in a military-only recreational league while in the armed forces.
"This is extremely frustrating. I think it's unfair, highly unfair," Rhodes told the Daily News Journal. "I just got out of the Marine Corps, and I wanted to play. For [the NCAA] to say, 'No, you can't play right now,' I just don't understand the logic in that."
At issue is an NCAA bylaw that punishes student-athletes who did not immediately enroll in college after leaving high school. Such students are docked one year of athletic eligibility for every year they participated in "organized competition" while out of school. The bylaw, 188.8.131.52.1, also requires them to sit out at least one season after enrolling in college, a practice called "redshirting."
Rhodes graduated from high school in 2007, then worked for a year before joining the Marines. Though Rhodes says his military football league was "like intramurals for us" with irregularly scheduled games, the NCAA ruled it constituted "organized competition" because it had officials and uniforms. Oh, and because the teams kept score.
The NCAA initially ruled that Rhodes would lose two years of eligibility because his rec league games fell during two academic years — he played two games in the winter of 2011, and another ten or so in the summer and fall of 2012. MTSU successfully appealed that decision, but the NCAA still said Rhodes had to sit out for the upcoming season before being eligible to play next year.
The bylaw keeping Rhodes off the field used to include an exemption for former members of the military, but that was scrapped somewhere along the line when the NCAA revised the rule.
On Monday, two national politicians came to Rhodes' defense. Rep. Scott DesJarlais (R-Tenn.), whose district includes Murfreesboro and the MTSU campus, wrote to NCAA President Tom Emmert urging him to review the case, and saying the collegiate athletics body was "using an obtuse interpretation of its own bylaws" to bar Rhodes from playing.
"While I think we would both agree that this particular rule and clause therein was never intended to punish or deter our nation's military personnel from having the opportunity to participate in NCAA sanctioned athletic events, that is exactly the scenario that is currently unfolding," he wrote.
Sen. John McCain (R-Ariz.), himself a notable military veteran, also expressed his support for Rhodes.
NCAA should allow Steven Rhodes to play - don’t penalize him for serving his country http://t.co/IliA7OmJFX— John McCain (@SenJohnMcCain) August 19, 2013
The NCAA has said it is reviewing the case, but has yet to issue a final decision on Rhodes' eligibility.
"The NCAA has provided an initial review of the case and will continue to work with the university," NCAA spokeswoman Stacy Osburn said in a statement Monday. "The process is ongoing and a final decision has not yet been made."
Update: Late Monday, the NCAA announced it had decided to let Rhodes play this season after all, adding that Rhodes would also retain all four years of athletic eligibility.
"As a part of the ongoing review of NCAA rules, our members will examine the organized competition rules, especially as it impacts those returning from military service," Kevin Lennon, vice president of academic and membership affairs, said in a brief statement. "We thank Steven for his service to our country and wish him the best as he begins college."
THE WEEK'S AUDIOPHILE PODCASTS: LISTEN SMARTER
- The 11 worst fast food restaurants in America
- I hate Ayn Rand — but here's why my fellow conservatives love her
- Here's the schedule very successful people follow every day
- The weird obsession that's ruining the GOP
- Why Peter Capaldi has a bigger challenge than any Doctor Who in history
- 7 grammar rules you really should pay attention to
- 7 things the world's happiest people do every day
- The secret to Gabrielle Hamilton's amazing grilled cheese sandwiches
- A scientific fact-check of 2001: A Space Odyssey
- What if The Purge was real?
Subscribe to the Week