n paper, Zurich's drive-through sex boxes sound like a prostitute's dream. Spaces equipped with showers and security alarms that can be rented for less than $6 a night seem like an efficient, affordable, and safe way for prostitutes to protect themselves and their business without the fear of violent pimps. Indeed, two months after their establishment, the sex boxes are being hailed as a great success by everyone.
Everyone that is, except the folks actually using them.
The voter-approved project, which cost $2.6 million, was designed to alleviate citizens' fears regarding prostitution. Although prostitution has been legal in Switzerland since 1942, locals were increasingly uneasy with the "presence of sex workers in residential areas," wrote Dr. Brooke Magnanti at The Telegraph. They also wanted create a safer space for prostitutes that would protect them from violence and assault.
This past week, government officials have been praising the sex boxes for successfully addressing all those concerns. "After two months, I can say this guarded prostitution is working," Michael Herzig, the director of social services for sex workers in Zurich, told the AFP. "We do not have any major problems, such as with pimps, violence, or the neighborhood."
The sex boxes even have friendly PSAs reminding people to use condoms, as well as on-site doctors and social workers. Who wouldn't love these magical sex boxes?
Well, for one, the prostitutes. While Herzig sees encouraging sex box numbers, others believe they are lackluster. On average, 14 of the 30 available sex boxes are used a night, which means they're operating under 50 percent capacity. In turn, this suggests the prostitutes don't love the program.
UK Metro reported that prostitutes have complained that the sex boxes are "bad for business" and "not worth our while." More specifically, prostitutes are complaining that the sex boxes attract few customers, writes Malcolm Curtis at Switzerland's The Local.
And it turns out, the johns feel similarly. Metro quoted a letter printed in a local newspaper in Zurich from a man complaining, "On a Saturday night, there were only three prostitutes there. That is not really a lot of choice."
Prostitutes also say they are taking a financial and emotional hit from the sex boxes. Director of Switzerland's Salvation Army prostitute rehabilitation program, Cornelia Zurrer Ritter, told Swiss newspaper Neue Zurcher Zeitung that the women who use sex boxes "make less money" and find the "working conditions inhumane."
While the sex boxes are safe, they are also, well, wooden boxes. Upon closer examination, they look more like unfinished sheds without any place to lie down. It's understandable that prostitutes find saloons and lounges that let them work indoors (and have pillows) more accommodating. In fact, it's predicted that many of them are just moving to these locales.
However, Zurich has been cracking down on brothels, closing ones that have been open for less than 20 years. Thus, more prostitutes end up out of work, especially if they are ditching the sex boxes to go indoors.
And unfortunately, when prostitutes move indoors and off the streets, they are both more vulnerable and further removed from help resources. "It has become even more difficult to get in contact with the prostitutes," the director of City Mission told Neue Zurcher Zeitung. "When the scene shifts, the women no longer where to find us."
THE WEEK'S AUDIOPHILE PODCASTS: LISTEN SMARTER
- The world's dumbest idea: Taxing solar energy
- 31 TV shows to watch in 2014
- Why would a young person today be religious?
- He said he was leaving. She ignored him.
- Why we can't stop procrastinating, according to science
- Israel and Russia are getting along. Have the neocons noticed?
- Why Holy Thursday is so important to Christians
- How Community's Dean Pelton broke new ground for sexual politics on television
- Why I'm a pro-life liberal
- Texas has been holding this man hostage for 12,600 days
Subscribe to the Week