RSS
Easter's deadly Ukrainian checkpoint battle makes no sense
Why would four cars of Ukrainian ultranationalist militants attack the fortified separatist town of Slovyansk?
 
A pro-Russia guard outside the separatist-held government building in Donetsk, Ukraine, just south of Slovyansk.
A pro-Russia guard outside the separatist-held government building in Donetsk, Ukraine, just south of Slovyansk. Scott Olson/Getty Images

There's very little that's clear yet about a deadly confrontation at a pro-Russia checkpoint outside the Ukrainian town of Slovyansk early Easter Sunday, but the casualties include at least three people, possibly five, and perhaps the peace deal signed Thursday by Ukraine, Russia, the European Union, and the U.S.

According to one account from a coordinator of the checkpoint, four vehicles drove up at about 3 a.m. and started firing at the pro-Russia guards, who returned fire with guns and Molotov cocktails; two vehicles were set aflame, and the survivors jumped in the other two and fled. Russia quickly embraced this version and accused Kiev of refusing to rein in "nationalists and extremists," notably the ultranationalist group Right Sector.

"Images emerged quickly on Russian television, showing a trove of evidence that was somehow retrieved unblemished from two smoldering attack vehicles — a bundle of U.S. dollars, Nazi-era weaponry, a satellite map of the region, and a telltale business card bearing the name of the Right Sector," says the Toronto Star's Mitch Potter.

The "pristine business card said to have been left behind by the attackers," says the AP's Yuras Karmanau, especially "was met with widespread ridicule in Ukraine, where it soon had its own Twitter hashtag." Right Sector (Pravy Sektor) also mocked the found card, bearing the name of group leader Dmytro Yarosh. "As if the militants of Pravy Sektor carry Yarosh's business cards with them!" spokesman Artyom Skoropadskiy tells the BBC, adding, "Right Sector was not there, and whatever happened there was an obvious provocation from the Russian secret services." The New York Times notes a few other fishy details:

The remains of a pickup truck and a sport utility vehicle sat in the center of the road, incinerated except for two unburned out-of-town license plates: one screwed onto a fender, the other merely set on a fender. Bullet holes in the pickup truck's driver-side door showed that the truck had been fired on from the side or from behind as it faced the checkpoint. [The New York Times]

Separately, The New York Times reports that photographic evidence strongly suggests that the "mysteriously well-armed, professional gunmen known as 'green men'" who have taken over government sites in eastern Ukraine are, despite denials from Moscow, Russian military and intelligence forces.

That doesn't explain what happened at the Slovyansk checkpoint, or how the locals feel about the very real loss of three townspeople — they're angry, and they blame Kiev, according to the Toronto Star's Potter. Slovyansk's separatist-appointed "people's mayor," Vyacheslav Ponomaryov, is asking Russia to send in "peacekeepers," and plenty of smart people think that's a real possibility.

The idea that Right Sector militants from the west would try to enter an unfriendly town in the east doesn't make much sense. But who would you trust, a group of neo-fascist Ukrainian nationalists you already dislike or the country you are asking for help?

 
Peter Weber is a senior editor at TheWeek.com, and has handled the editorial night shift since 2008. A graduate of Northwestern University, Peter has worked at Facts on File and The New York Times Magazine. He speaks Spanish and Italian, and plays in an Austin rock band.

THE WEEK'S AUDIOPHILE PODCASTS: LISTEN SMARTER

Subscribe to the Week