RSS
Gratitude as Bush bows out
Should Americans be thankful for what he did, or for the fact that he's leaving?
W

hat happened
President Bush said in a televised farewell address that he had some setbacks during his eight years in office, but had always done "what I thought was right." (The New York Times) Bush said his administration's main achievement was keeping the nation safe after the terrorist attacks of Sept. 11, 2001, that shaped his presidency. (Chicago Tribune)

What the commentators said
"It's hard to see someone leave the presidency so shamed," said Joan Walsh in Salon. Bush's televised goodbye was pathetic—he "sounded like a kid reciting the high points of fourth grade." Thank goodness Jan. 20 will soon be here, "because this president has damaged the nation beyond what I'm certain our next president can fix."

Ingrate, said W. Todd Akin in The Washington Times. As Bush prepares to leave the White House, Americans owe him a thank you, especially for the "primary focus" he placed on protecting us all following Sept. 11. His "pro-active approach may be criticized, but it worked."

Attacking Iraq and failing to finish the job in Afghanistan didn't make us safe, said David Corn in CQ Politics. Giving Bush credit for that is like thanking a rooster for crowing and making the sun rise. What really defines Bush's presidency is that he is leaving the "country burdened with two unresolved wars and an economy in severe decline."

"Except for Richard Nixon, no president since Harry Truman has left office more unloved than George W. Bush," said Charles Krauthammer in The Washington Post. Truman's rehabilitation took decades, but Bush's has already begun. And the main revisionist is Barack Obama, whose "continuity-we-can-believe-in transition" has served as a tacit endorsement on Bush's policies on everything from the economy to the war on terror.

EDITORS' PICKS

THE WEEK'S AUDIOPHILE PODCASTS: LISTEN SMARTER

Subscribe to the Week