Reality TV»

American Idol

American Idol : The List
The judges of ABC's "Duets" sing on stage in the season premiere: Like "The Voice," "Duets" pairs unknowns with celebrity mentors in weekly competitions.

The coming glut of American Idol ripoffs: A guide

As latest Idol winner Phillip Phillips picks confetti out of his hair, four new reality TV singing competitions are already gearing up to crown the next sensation

 
American Idol : Opinion Brief
Jennifer Holliday's guest performance on "American Idol" Thursday night is all anyone can talk about, but it wasn't her voice that made the lasting impression.

Jennifer Holliday and Jessica Sanchez's bizarre American Idol duet

The original Dreamgirls star joins the Idol runner-up on Wednesday's finale, and delivers a series of wild facial contortions hailed as both ludicrous and brilliant

 
American Idol : Opinion Brief
Underdog Jessica Sanchez is a pitch-perfect (if bland) belter, while frontrunner Phillip Phillips sometimes struggles to carry a tune.

American Idol finale: Should Jessica Sanchez win?

The teen belter was outshone by Philip Phillips, a handsome Dave Matthews sound-alike, on Tuesday. But the franchise desperately needs a female winner

 
American Idol : Opinion Brief
Joshua Ledet is comforted by a distraught Jennifer Lopez after being voted off during last night's "American Idol."

American Idol: Did Joshua Ledet deserve to get kicked off?

The throwback crooner was the judges' hands-down favorite, and some are complaining that the show's fans are biased towards white guys with guitars

 
American Idol : Opinion Brief
"American Idol" judges have tongue-bathed contestant Joshua Ledet, but his musical tastes may be too old-school to earn him a wide following.

Is Joshua Ledet really the best American Idol singer ever?

The show's judges showered the young contestant with unhinged praise after his Wednesday performance, and some Idol fans were turned off by the favoritism

 
American Idol : Opinion Brief
Ryan Seacrest just renewed his "American Idol" contract for a cool $15 million a year, which knocks him up to judge Jennifer Lopez's level.

American Idol: Is Ryan Seacrest worth $15 million a year?

Seacrest just signed a blockbuster contract to host the reality TV juggernaut for two more seasons, raising questions about his actual value

 
American Idol : Fact Sheet
"The Voice" judges, including Cee Lo Green, double as coaches which makes them more invested and critical of the show's performers.

4 reasons The Voice is blowing American Idol away

For 10 seasons, the Fox juggernaut has been dominating the airwaves. But now NBC's fledgling singing competition is proving more popular — and for good reason

 
American Idol : Burning Question
American Idol returned Wednesday night and light-hearted judges Jennifer Lopez and Steven Tyler haven't gotten any more critical over the break.

American Idol's 'hopeful' return: 4 burning questions

In a cramped field of rival singing competitions, can the venerable Fox hit still rule? And is it risky for judge Jennifer Lopez to experience the "goosies"?

 
American Idol : Analysis
With Ryan Seacrest's contract running out after the upcoming season of "American Idol," some critics say Fox should do everything in its power to hold onto the popular host.

Would American Idol still succeed without Ryan Seacrest?

With the consummate host's contract with the reality TV competition set to expire, pundits are imagining a "Seacrest, out" scenario

 
American Idol : Instant Guide
Spot the difference: Simon Cowell on his last season of American Idol in 2009 (above) and Simon Cowell on the debut of his new singing competition show The X Factor Wednesday (below).

The X Factor vs. American Idol: 6 key differences

Simon Cowell and Paula Abdul are back assessing hopeful singers and sipping cola. How is this reality competition any different from Idol?

 
American Idol : Opinion Brief
Simon Cowell returns to the judges table on "The X-Factor," airing this fall, with fellow "American Idol" alum Paula Abdul.

The X Factor preview: Is Simon Cowell's new show a winner?

The former American Idol judge gives audiences a (satisfyingly harsh) taste of his new Fox singing competition — and gets in a few jabs at his alma mater

 
American Idol : Forecast
Former "American Idol" judges Paula Abdul and Simon Cowell will reunite for "The X Factor," Fox's new singing competition, which will air this fall.

Will Paula Abdul help The X Factor beat American Idol?

Reuniting Idol's kookiest ex-judge with Simon Cowell could be the key to the new singing competition show's success

 
American Idol : Opinion Brief
In order to sit up front at 'American Idol," says one offended audience member, it seems you have to fit a particular mold: Young, thin and pretty.

'American Idol': Too fat for the front row?

The reality show comes under fire after an audience member is reportedly told she's "too fat" to sit in full camera view

 
American Idol : Controversy
Toothless new judges Steven Tyler and Jennifer Lopez seem to hail from the land of "Stepford," says Newsweek.

Does 'American Idol' need meaner judges?

Viewers just got their first glimpse of new judges Steven Tyler and Jennifer Lopez in action. Can the rookies measure up to the brutally discerning Simon Cowell?

 
American Idol : Opinion Brief
While no rival singing show yet topped "American Idol," Fox's powerhouse series is entering uncharted territory in 2011 with new judges Steven Tyler and Jennifer Lopez.

'American Idol' vs. NBC's upstart show

The Peacock Network is challenging Fox's aging "Idol" with a new show called "The Voice of America." Will audiences embrace NBC's contender?

 
American Idol : Opinion Brief
New "American Idol" judge Jennifer Lopez will be joining Steven Tyler, Randy Jackson and Ryan Seacrest now on Wednesday and Thursday nights on Fox.

Why is Fox rescheduling 'American Idol'?

The decision to move "Idol" to Wednesday and Thursday nights shocked critics. Is it smart to tinker with a successful prime-time formula?

 

Facebook

Twitter

Stumble

Tumblr

RSS

Newsletter

See our bad opinions
Lauren Odes

A lingerie store fires a staffer for being too buxom — and more in our collection of strange revelations about the nation

Can you guess what's really going on in these bizarre photos?

Get The Week iPad app
Get The Week iPad app