Feature

United Kingdom: A case of too much empathy

With Twitter and Facebook “fizzing temptingly at everyone’s fingertips,” too many of us “have forgotten when to stop communicating,” said Jenny McCartney in The Telegraph.

Jenny McCartney
The Telegraph

Was the Facebooking juror treated too harshly? asked Jenny McCartney. Manchester mother-of-three Joanne Fraill, who was serving on a jury at a drug trial, has just been sentenced to eight months in prison for contempt of court after messaging one of the defendants via Facebook. Fraill “sobbed uncontrollably” as she heard the sentence, which is longer than many a term handed out to violent criminals. And it’s hard not to sympathize with her.

“For Fraill, the trial had become a soap opera, and the defendants were its players: She suffered from a destructive excess of empathy.” She contacted the defendant, Jamie Sewart, who had just been acquitted but whose co-defendants still awaited their verdicts, and in the course of gushing her sympathy, she “revealed sensitive details of the jury’s ongoing deliberations.”

The result was the scuppering of a multi-million-pound trial. Sending Fraill to jail is intended to deter others from such inappropriate outreach. But given “the slippery interface between a culture of limitless disclosure” and the jury system’s requirement for absolute discretion, that’s an unlikely result. With Twitter and Facebook “fizzing temptingly at everyone’s fingertips,” too many of us “have forgotten when to stop communicating.”

Recommended

Internal report blames Johnson, senior leadership for lockdown parties
Boris Johnson
partygate

Internal report blames Johnson, senior leadership for lockdown parties

Biden's promise to defend Taiwan
President Biden.
Picture of Harold MaassHarold Maass

Biden's promise to defend Taiwan

No time to evacuate as Russian forces close in on a pair of Ukrainian cities
Ukrainian tank in Sievierodonetsk
encirclement in luhansk

No time to evacuate as Russian forces close in on a pair of Ukrainian cities

Would the U.S. really defend Taiwan from a Chinese invasion?
President Biden and Xi Jinping.
Briefing

Would the U.S. really defend Taiwan from a Chinese invasion?

Most Popular

Trump loses his grip on a Trumpified GOP
Donald Trump.
Opinion

Trump loses his grip on a Trumpified GOP

'Why are we willing to live with this carnage?'
Uvalde, Texas.
Briefing

'Why are we willing to live with this carnage?'

21 dead in shooting at Texas elementary school
A Texas State Police officer at Robb Elementary School in Uvalde, Texas.
tragedy strikes

21 dead in shooting at Texas elementary school