The video: Is Beyonce a copycat? The accusation has plagued the singer before, with cries that her "Single Ladies" video clearly stole iconic Bob Fosse dance moves. And a recent performance of "Run the World (Girls)" allegedly ripped off a similar stage show by an Italian singer. Now, esteemed Belgian choreographer Teresa De Keersmaeker is charging plagiarism, arguing that Beyonce's "Countdown" video, released last week, steals choreography, costuming, and staging from two of her own pieces: "Rosas danst Rosas" and "Achterland." A helpful YouTube video intersperses the key "Countdown" moves with De Keersmaeker's work. (See the comparison below.) For her part, Beyonce says her video was inspired by "Rosas danst Rosas," but rejects accusations that it was plagiarized.
The reaction: The "Copycat Queen" can't deny that this is "blatant imitation," says Thy Black Man. She needs to "stop passing off other people's work as her own." Hold on, says Emily Abbate at The Stir. The video is "more of a tribute to the original than a slap in the face." Despite similarities, Beyonce "throws her own flair into the mix." Everyone knows that "works of art often reference other works of art," agrees Luke Jennings at the U.K.'s Guardian. Besides, says Luke Jennings at the U.K.'s Guardian, Beyonce's video also draws inspiration from Audrey Hepburn, Flashdance, and the Supremes. Still, maybe it's time she "at least paid [other artists] and/or asked for their permission before sampling their work." See for yourself:
Subscribe to The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
-
Gaza Humanitarian Foundation: the group behind Gaza's controversial new aid programmeThe Explainer Deadly shootings and chaotic scenes have been reported at aid sites after US group replaced UN humanitarian organisations
-
Is UK's new defence plan transformational or too little, too late?Today's Big Question Labour's 10-year strategy 'an exercise in tightly bounded ambition' already 'overshadowed by a row over money'
-
How much should doctors trust parental intuition?In The Spotlight Study finds parents' concern can be better at spotting critical illness than vital signs
