Feature

Timothy Geithner’s banking rescue

Why the markets love—and Paul Krugman hates—the Obama team’s new plan to save the economy

The stock market “totally loves” Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner’s new program to clean up the banking mess, said Daniel Gross in Slate. But liberal New York Times columnist Paul Krugman (read his column) says the plan, which offers subsidies to get investors to buy bad mortgage assets from ailing banks, is nothing but "financial hocus-pocus." It's indeed puzzling that investors are now such “girly-men” that we need to “bribe” them to take risks.

It’s disheartening that Krugman is “filled with a sense of despair,” said Steven Pearlstein in The Washington Post. But Geithner’s plan actually has a good shot at cleaning up banks’ balance sheets a bit, letting them raise private capital and return to lending. That is the government’s goal—to revive the financial sector as cheaply as possible—and if this works, the bribes to lure in investors will be a small price.

Geithner’s plan is “logical,” said Justin Fox in Time. But if it fails—if, as Krugman argues, it’s “insufficient” to fix the crisis, or too complicated, or seen as a sweetheart deal for banks or certain investors—the political and financial fallout will be huge. Still, Geithner isn’t making a “crazy bet” that the subsidies will help banks and investors finally set mutually acceptable prices on the toxic assets.

It’s still a bet, said The New York Times in an editorial, and it won’t pay off unless some iffy “assumptions about the future” are correct. If the assets are priced too high, or are worth less than forecast, taxpayers lose. Obama needs to explain why his team isn’t taking the time-tested route: finding, taking over, and restructuring the insolvent banks.

Something like the savings-and-loan-era Resolution Trust Corp. would have been “simpler,” said The Wall Street Journal in an editorial, but Geithner’s plan “isn’t the worst idea the federal government has ever had.” The best thing about it may be that Geithner finally has a strategy. That’s one reason why the markets “roared their approval”—it'll mean less uncertainty.

Recommended

Honduran opposition candidate Xiomara Castro leads in presidential returns
Xiomara Castro
Honduras Votes

Honduran opposition candidate Xiomara Castro leads in presidential returns

Dutch health ministry confirms 13 cases of Omicron
hugo de jonge
Omicron in the low countries

Dutch health ministry confirms 13 cases of Omicron

Swiss voters uphold COVID restrictions in referendum
swiss covid protesters
Swiss miss their chance

Swiss voters uphold COVID restrictions in referendum

Taiwanese air force warns off Chinese incursion
taiwanese air force
buzz off!

Taiwanese air force warns off Chinese incursion

Most Popular

7 cartoons about Thanksgiving inflation
Political Cartoon.
Feature

7 cartoons about Thanksgiving inflation

Who pays America's taxes?
Taxes.
Briefing

Who pays America's taxes?

Should anti-vaxxers get unemployment benefits?
A handout.
Picture of Joel MathisJoel Mathis

Should anti-vaxxers get unemployment benefits?