Opinion

Vaccines and risk

The human brain tends to make us fear the wrong threats

This is the editor's letter in the current issue of The Week magazine.

The human brain has two systems for assessing risk, and one isn't very reliable. The neocortex, which developed relatively late in human evolution, can make rational, risk-reward assessments based on evidence, data, and logic. The amygdala, a more primitive region we share with other mammals, reacts instantly to perceived threats with fear, anxiety, and the fight-or-flight response. Strong emotions often overrule logic, so our brains are biased to overreact to exotic risks like terrorism, plane crashes, and tarantulas, while downplaying the much greater likelihood we'll die of the flu, a car crash, heart disease — or COVID. For the past year, the pandemic has made us all subjects in a massive experiment on human risk assessment. We haven't done very well. Too many Americans decided that going about their usual activities without a mask or social distancing didn't feel as risky as the experts were saying ... and as a result, they caught and spread an invisible contagion. More than 560,000 have died.

Now our brains are assessing the risk of getting vaccinated vs. going unprotected against COVID. That task was complicated this week with the discovery that six women out of the 7 million people who received the Johnson & Johnson vaccine developed blood clots — a rate of 0.00008 percent. By way of perspective, an unvaccinated American's risk of dying of COVID is 1 in 1,666, and the risk COVID will cause severe illness and lasting, "long haul" symptoms is far greater. But the "pause" in J&J vaccinations, while ethical and responsible, will undoubtedly harden the resistance of the 30 percent who say they will not take any vaccine. That would be a terrible outcome — for them and for the rest of us. The pandemic won't truly subside until vaccinations give the coronavirus vanishingly few new people to infect. Those whose amygdalae are wrongly telling them vaccines are riskier than COVID may well determine when, and if, life returns to normal.

More From...

Picture of William FalkWilliam Falk
Read All
Bill Russell's legacy
Bill Russell
Talking Points

Bill Russell's legacy

The great COVID disconnect
People in Times Square.
Opinion

The great COVID disconnect

The turning point
Trump.
Talking Points

The turning point

The soul of a machine
Ones and zeroes.
Talking Points

The soul of a machine

Recommended

John Oliver explains monkeypox
John Oliver
Johnsplaining

John Oliver explains monkeypox

The gaps in the nation's monkeypox response
Monkeypox vaccine
Brigid Kennedy

The gaps in the nation's monkeypox response

Monkeypox now public health emergency
Xavier Becerra.
i do declare

Monkeypox now public health emergency

Polio virus found in wastewater sample in NYC, health officials urge residents to get vaccinated
Polio Vaccine
it's back?

Polio virus found in wastewater sample in NYC, health officials urge residents to get vaccinated

Most Popular

How the U.S. killed Al Qaeda's leader, and no one else, with a flying 'knife bomb'
unmanned aerial vehicle
Briefing

How the U.S. killed Al Qaeda's leader, and no one else, with a flying 'knife bomb'

Amazon to buy Roomba maker for $1.7 billion
Roomba
the panamazopticon expands

Amazon to buy Roomba maker for $1.7 billion

Kim Kardashian and Pete Davidson break up
Kim Kardashian and Pete Davidson
the saga ends

Kim Kardashian and Pete Davidson break up