"It's been two weeks since 'Mean Girls', and here we go again," said Kevin Maher in The Times: another "film adaptation of a stage musical adaptation of an original, much-adored movie". And beneath it all, there is Alice Walker's Pulitzer Prize-winning novel. But in this version, "Walker's poetic prose, religious themes and epistolary structure" have vanished, under a "plethora of incongruous show tunes".
So, as in the book, the resilient Celie (Fantasia Barrino) is repeatedly raped by her stepfather in early 20th century Georgia, and forced to give up the babies she bears as a result – but "now she intersperses the torture with jazzy dance routines". And when she is sold to the deranged Mister (Colman Domingo), who tries to rape her sister Nettie (Halle Bailey) then "beats Celie into a stupor over the next three decades", she has "some nifty melodies for comfort".
The cast are "fine", and director Blitz Bazawule does bring "pizzazz" to the film, but "'Historical Racism: The Feelgood Musical' was always going to be a hard sell".
The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
It's not a subtle film, said Robbie Collin in The Daily Telegraph: "an all-singing, all-sobbing weepie", it is filled with sequins and features some "uproarious choreography". But its "suite of soul, R&B and gospel numbers" will have you "bopping along"; and though it's pretty saccharine, I "snaffled up" every minute of it.
Of all the adaptations of Walker's book I've seen, this is my favourite, said Kyle Smith in The Wall Street Journal. Sure, the characters are "broadly drawn", but the film "elicits all the hugs and tears you could expect from holiday entertainment, and then some".
Sign up to The Week's Arts & Life newsletter for more reviews and recommendations.
-
The ‘menopause gold rush’Under the Radar Women vulnerable to misinformation and marketing of ‘unregulated’ products
-
Voting Rights Act: SCOTUS’s pivotal decisionFeature A Supreme Court ruling against the Voting Rights Act could allow Republicans to redraw districts and solidify control of the House
-
No Kings rally: What did it achieve?Feature The latest ‘No Kings’ march has become the largest protest in U.S. history
-
8 of the best horror comedy films of all timeThe Week Recommends From parodies to ‘requels,’ these movies will make you laugh and scream at the same time
-
Roasted squash and apple soup recipeThe Week Recommends Autumnal soup is full of warming and hearty flavours
-
The 5 best TV shows about the mobThe Week Recommends From the show that launched TV’s golden age to a Batman spin-off, viewers can’t get enough of these magnificent mobsters
-
6 well-crafted log homesFeature Featuring a floor-to-ceiling rock fireplace in Montana and a Tulikivi stove in New York
-
Dry skin, begone! 8 products to keep your skin supple while traveling.The Week Recommends Say goodbye to dry and hello to hydration
-
Film reviews: A House of Dynamite, After the Hunt, and It Was Just an AccidentFeature A nuclear missile bears down on a U.S. city, a sexual misconduct allegation rocks an elite university campus, and a victim of government terror pursues vengeance
-
Book reviews: ‘Gertrude Stein: An Afterlife’ and ‘Make Me Commissioner: I Know What’s Wrong With Baseball and How to Fix It’Feature Gertrude Stein’s untold story and Jane Leavy’s playbook on how to save baseball
-
Rachel Ruysch: Nature Into ArtFeature Museum of Fine Arts, Boston, through Dec. 7
