More than 3,500 children in Gaza "face imminent death by starvation" after more than two months of total blockade by Israel, Gaza's Hamas-run Government Media Office has warned.
Israel halted all supplies of humanitarian aid, including food, water and medicines, in March in a bid to pressure Hamas into releasing the remaining Israeli hostages. The UN World Food Programme reported two weeks ago that it had run out of food stocks for families in Gaza. International organisations are accusing Israel of weaponising starvation and humanitarian aid: a war crime.
What did the commentators say? "A full-blown humanitarian emergency in Gaza is no longer looming," said Sean Carroll, president of the non-profit group American Near East Refugee Aid, in The New York Times. "It is here, and it is catastrophic." Two million Palestinians, nearly half of them children, are "surviving on a single meal every two or three days", and signs of "prolonged starvation are becoming more frequent and alarming". This is a "moment of moral reckoning" for the world.
Israel's serial blockades are a "major test for international law", said Boyd van Dijk, a Geneva Conventions expert, in Foreign Affairs. In November, the International Criminal Court issued arrest warrants for Benjamin Netanyahu and his former defence minister Yoav Gallant, alleging a "rarely invoked" war crime: "orchestrating a criminal starvation policy" against Gazans. Yet despite a "long and devastating history" of intentional starvation of civilians in conflict, it is "notoriously difficult to prove".
The top UN court, the International Court of Justice, separately began hearings last week aimed at determining whether Israel had a legal duty to allow aid into Gaza and to lift its ban on the UN's Palestinian aid agency, UNRWA. The "strong legal consensus" is that Israel has an "absolute duty under the Geneva Conventions" to allow food in, said The Guardian. After all, "withholding food kills, just as bombs do".
What next? Israel has refused to appear before the ICJ court in The Hague and is reportedly planning to resume aid delivery "in the coming weeks", said The Guardian, but through a "radically new mechanism". Israel still claims that UNRWA – "essential to humanitarian efforts" – has been "mass-infiltrated by Hamas", an allegation the UN strongly disputes. But its proposed alternative – international organisations and private contractors handing out food – "looks both unworkable and dangerous for civilians". |