Inmates in an acting group tap hidden strengths.
"A film like Sing Sing is a rare, precious achievement," said Katie Walsh in the Los Angeles Times. "Hewed from the heart" and "quietly captivating," this drama set in upstate New York's Sing Sing prison focuses on a group of inmates working to stage their first original play, but it's also "about so much more," including the hope, heartbreak, and chance at personal growth that exist wherever human lives unfold. The star, Colman Domingo, provides the film its "beating, bleeding heart." But the recent Oscar nominee is surrounded by men who've actually participated in Sing Sing's theater program, and Domingo gives them space to shine when their big moments arrive. "The discovery here is Clarence Maclin," one of several Sing Sing alums, said Justin Chang in The New Yorker. Early on, his character "bullies, extorts, and hurls threats at the slightest provocation," and when he's recruited into the acting group, he at first rebels against the leadership of Domingo's Divine G before the two develop a deep, believable friendship.Â
Unfortunately, Greg Kwedar's movie is "too neatly divided" between the textured realism of the prison world it shows us and the "charmingly cornball" redemption story it tells. "You come away from Sing Sing wanting more of the characters, more of their lives." Still, it's hard not to be moved when the amateur actors throw themselves into the performance of the nutty, genre-bending comedy they've devised for their fellow inmates' amusement, said Stephanie Zacharek in Time. "If a group of forgotten men can pull this sort of thing off, then what excuse do the rest of us have? Outside prison walls or within them, those who stop growing have only themselves to blame." |