by Rachel Cockerell
Melting Point is “a book unlike anything I’ve ever read,” said Kathryn Schulz in The New Yorker. It tells the story of a little-known attempt to build an American homeland for European Jews by encouraging thousands to sail to Galveston, Texas, and it places that endeavor in the context of the broader early-20th-century effort to create a Jewish homeland in Palestine or elsewhere. Because author Rachel Cockerell tells the tale entirely through snippets from primary sources, such as diary entries, newspaper reports, and interview transcripts, the characters and events “feel startlingly present.” Besides, “only so vast a chorus of voices could do justice to the larger story: the history of an imperiled people and their courageous, blinkered, desperate effort to find a place to call home.”
Cockerell’s great-grandfather was a pivotal figure in launching the Galveston plan, and she relies on him to make her story cohere, said Lucy Hughes-Hallett in The Guardian. That “doesn’t quite work,” because David Jochelman, her forebear, is a less striking figure than his main allies, Theodor Herzl and Israel Zangwill. Herzl was the dashing Hungarian Jewish journalist who predicted the devastation of European Jewry and died at 44, just eight years after fathering the movement to create a Jewish state. Zangwill, a playwright, was the most popular Jewish writer working in English, and he and Jochelman split from mainline Zionism to advocate for alternatives to Palestine. East Africa, Western Australia, Mexico, and Libya were all explored as possibilities before Galveston emerged as their faction’s favored option. By 1914, 10,000 European Jews had arrived at the Texas port, and the “most compelling” section of Cockerell’s “formally ingenious” book is over.
But the family story continues, and in a book “with many distinct voices,” it’s Cockerell’s half-aunt Jo who proves most engaging, said Alice Kaplan in The New York Review of Books. Jo helps tie eras together, enabling Cockerell to create a personal connection, through a relative who moved to Palestine, to the clashes of the late 1940s that displaced some 800,000 Palestinian Arabs and established the nation of Israel. Because Cockerell never voices an opinion, she “avoids the question that will occur to most of her readers today: What if Zion had been established somewhere else?” But the reports she provides of the Palestinian Arabs’ displacement are “every bit as horrendous” as the accounts of a 1903 anti-Jewish pogrom she cites earlier. In the end, her “deeply satisfying” book “makes us hear how the yearning for a homeland, an essential part of Jewish history, is mirrored in Palestinian suffering. ‘Where can we go? What can we do?’ Even the words are the same.” |