An era-spanning mega mix of the 1984 hit "Do They Know It's Christmas?" will be released this year to mark its anniversary and to raise more money for charity. The new track will blend vocals from different versions of the single to make stars such as George Michael, Sinead O'Connor, Bono and Harry Styles sing "together".
But "not everybody is happy about it", said London's The Standard. The 40th anniversary remix has been "denounced" by Ed Sheeran, who claimed his voice had been used "without permission". The singer appeared on the 30th anniversary version of the track, but said in an Instagram that his "understanding of the narrative associated" with the song had since changed. Given the choice, he said, "I would have respectfully declined the use of my vocals".
'Not aged well' The original release of "Do They Know It's Christmas?", by an all-star line-up of artists entitled Band Aid, was put together by Boomtown Rats frontman Bob Geldof and Ultravox singer Midge Ure.
But the festive hit "has not aged well", said Deadline. Critics say the lyrics "perpetuate racist and patronising stereotypes of African people", and although later releases have "tweaked" some of the wording, the original version "remains the standard" for the airwaves every Christmas.
'Keeping millions alive' The Band Aid Charitable Trust is believed to have raised more than £140 million over the past four decades, and spawned Live Aid, the 1985 concert, and Live 8, a similar project in 2005.
Fundraising has become "much more of a spectacle" in recent years, said Colin Alexander, senior lecturer in political communications at Nottingham Trent University, on The Conversation. Celebrities view charitable endorsements "as a key part of their star profile", and instances of "poverty porn have also become commonplace across the charity sector". But a negative outcome is that the recipients of donations are reduced "to mere 'victims' rather than full humans looking for agency".
Responding to Alexander's article, Geldof said his "little pop song has kept hundreds of thousands if not millions of people alive", and meant that many can "sleep safer, warmer and cared for tonight". |