After debuting to hyperbolic praise, the new HBO series Girls faced its first backlash from critics decrying its caucasian-centric depiction of New York City. The startlingly honest comedy — which 25-year-old Lena Dunham created, directs, writes, and stars in — follows four twenty-something white friends navigating post-grad life in New York City. But with non-white characters unrealistically absent from early episodes, critics complained that a series packaged as "the twenty-something experience" had "a serious problem when it comes to race." Dunham directly addressed those critiques in an interview with NPR, arguing that she based the show on her own experiences as a "half-Jew, half-WASP." She felt she couldn't write truthfully about an African American girl living in New York, and wanted to avoid tokenism when casting the show. Should her defense satisfy critics?
The response is perfect: Dunham's NPR interview shows just how smart she is, says Amos Barshad at Grantland. She's completely aware, and also apologetic, that she wasn't able to provide viewers with a "truly all-encompassing rendition of young girls in New York right now." More importantly, she realizes that her show gives her a massive platform, acknowledges her "responsibility to be fair with that platform" and promises that people of color will be more prominent in season two. So we'll have to wait until next year to see if she and her co-writers pull it off. "But at least she's listening."
"Lena Dunham talks about Girls being super white"
She's making it worse: Dunham's only backing herself further into a corner, says Molly Friedman at Wetpaint. There are basically two ways to read her statement: Either she can't write about African American women because she's not one, or because she doesn't know one. Neither is a valid excuse. While Girls is appealing because its dialogue rings so true — likely a byproduct of a writer who's speaking from experience — TV writers have scripted characters different than themselves for decades. Girls' problem doesn't stem from Dunham's lack of experience outside her own race. It suggests, simply, a "lack of imagination."
"Lena Dunham responds to Girls' race-related criticism: 'This is a hard issue'"
Dunham couldn't win either way: If Dunham doubts her ability to convey the experiences of well-rounded black characters, as she says, says Jenee Desmond-Harris at The Root, it's for the best that she didn't even try. After all, we're often quick to complain about negative, stereotypical portrayals of black women in Hollywood, and we'd be just as quick to "throw her under the bus if she did cast a 'token' black girl and got it wrong."
"Girls creator explains lack of color"
THE WEEK'S AUDIOPHILE PODCASTS: LISTEN SMARTER
- How to be the most productive person in your office — and still get home by 5:30 p.m.
- 43 TV shows to watch in 2014
- Watch out, China — America is working on dogfighting drones
- How liberals are unwittingly paving the way for the legalization of adult incest
- Ted Cruz is the new Sarah Palin
- How the Simpsons/Family Guy crossover revealed the worst of both shows
- Libertarianism's terrible, horrible, no good, very bad idea
- Why you probably don't have Ebola — even if you shook hands with America's 'patient zero'
- Bill O'Reilly and Stephen Colbert are accidentally having a serious debate on ISIS
- Fall film guide: All the movies you should see in October
Subscribe to the Week