A win for FOIA fighters
One of the most powerful formal checks on government secrecy is the Freedom of Information Act, which compels the government to produce documents upon demand, with some exceptions. Since 1966, as you might imagine, the scope of the exceptions has been the subject of a significant amount of litigation. As you might also imagine, the government likes to define the exceptions broadly, and public advocacy groups like to define it narrowly.
In general, courts have been reluctant to side with the public in cases involving agencies involved in the national security state, specifically if a "national interest" type of exemption is cited. After all, the executive branch controls what constitutes national security information and decides how to protect it.
A group dedicated to monitoring the Ft. Benning, Ga.-based "Western Hemisphere Institute for Security Cooperation," a military school that trains foreign soldiers, alleged that the Department of Defense illegally withheld information by improperly and overbroadly citing exemptions. The institute used to be known as the School of the Americas; some of its graduates have been implicated in brutalities, and the government has promised to keep those folks with bad human rights records from attending. But the group, SOA Watch, found, based on its previous FOIA requests, that soldiers with questionable human rights records had in fact been allowed to attend the school, and forwarded this information to Congress in 2004. The DoD stopped providing the names to the watchdog group.
Subscribe to The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
It filed a FOIA request in 2011, and the Defense Department originally cited "exemption b(3)," which protects the privacy of people with a statutory right to it, as the reason for not releasing any of the names of students and military units. But after SOA Watch challenged the denial, the Defense Department added "exemption b(6)" to their list of reasons for not disclosing the information. That's the exemption that allows federal agencies to deny respondents information when the secretary of a particular department determines it's in the national interest.
Today, a judge reversed a long-standing habit of deferring on this exemption, and concluded that the FOIA agency has the burden to demonstrate why release would not be in the national interest. The Pentagon did a lot of asserting in its legal briefs, but not a lot of proving. (One claim: If the names of those who attend are released, they might be subject to harm back home, since many of them come from countries where being a law enforcement officer is dangerous. But the DoD did not find a way to prove their names were kept secret in their country of origin.)
There will be an appeal, of course, but the burden is now on the government to say why it must not be burdened with the justification of citing and asserting various FOIA exemptions.
This decision is the second major FOIA win for activists this month. In early April, an appeals court ruled that FOIA agencies must not only acknowledge having received a FOIA request within 20 days of getting one, but they must also give the requester information about what documents will be forthcoming, and which won't be.
Sign up for Today's Best Articles in your inbox
A free daily email with the biggest news stories of the day – and the best features from TheWeek.com
Create an account with the same email registered to your subscription to unlock access.
Marc Ambinder is TheWeek.com's editor-at-large. He is the author, with D.B. Grady, of The Command and Deep State: Inside the Government Secrecy Industry. Marc is also a contributing editor for The Atlantic and GQ. Formerly, he served as White House correspondent for National Journal, chief political consultant for CBS News, and politics editor at The Atlantic. Marc is a 2001 graduate of Harvard. He is married to Michael Park, a corporate strategy consultant, and lives in Los Angeles.
-
Baltimore bridge disaster: Who is going to pay and how?
Today's Big Question Politicians, legal experts, and the insurance industry are all grappling with the financial fallout of America's worst infrastructure tragedy in years
By Rafi Schwartz, The Week US Published
-
Melting polar ice is messing with global timekeeping
Speed Read Ice loss caused by climate change is slowing the Earth's rotation
By Peter Weber, The Week US Published
-
The Week contest: Stick guitar
Puzzles and Quizzes
By The Week US Published
-
Why Puerto Rico is starving
The Explainer Thanks to poor policy design, congressional dithering, and a hostile White House, hundreds of thousands of the most vulnerable Puerto Ricans are about to go hungry
By Jeff Spross Published
-
China is now just another autocracy
The Explainer On the long-lasting consequences of Xi Jinping's power grab
By Noah Millman Published
-
Is America the main obstacle to peace in Korea?
The Explainer There's only one way Korea would unify — and the United States won't stand for it
By Noah Millman Published
-
Why on Earth does the Olympics still refer to hundreds of athletes as 'ladies'?
The Explainer Stop it. Just stop.
By Jeva Lange Last updated
-
Berlin's wall and ours
The Explainer What that signifier of the Cold War indicates about our unsettled historical moment
By Noah Millman Published
-
The catastrophe in Yemen
The Explainer A Saudi Arabian blockade has left millions of civilians starving, and without fuel or clean water. What is this conflict about?
By The Week Staff Published
-
China's strongman
The Explainer Xi Jinping is China's most powerful leader in decades. What are his plans for the country — and the world?
By The Week Staff Published
-
How to ride out the apocalypse in a big city
The Explainer So you live in a city and don't want to die a fiery death ...
By Eugene K. Chow Published