How tourists cripple local economies by overpaying
Generosity can lead to some nasty economic side effects
I always feel uncomfortable about how much I tip in impoverished countries. Should it be more, just because? That person was nice and attentive…
Tourists can sometimes be put in a weird position when it comes to tipping and even just paying for goods or services abroad, especially when their spending power eclipses the local economy. I've found I most often wrestle with all sorts of mixed emotions and confusion related to payment and tipping when I'm visiting developing countries.
(More from Map Happy: Avoid taxi scams like a pro)
Subscribe to The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
Halfway through my trip in India, the strap on my only purse broke. Our guide took a quick detour to the side of the road at a busy intersection in Jaipur where a white-haired cobbler with leathery skin worked, barefoot and hunched over in the blazing sun. He put aside his other work to quickly and expertly fix my bag, while he talked back and forth with my guide the whole time. In the end I paid 50 rupees, or less than $1, which was the price my guide relayed to me.
I couldn't understand the exchange between my guide and the cobbler but it looked like haggling. I asked my guide afterward what the discussion had been about. The cobbler wanted 100 rupees for the job because I was a foreigner, which was something like quadruple the going price. I didn't know how to react. I felt ashamed I had paid so little, even though I had still overpaid. I definitely had the means to pay the $1.60 he originally wanted. The difference was negligible to me but it clearly made a difference to him.
There's also the feeling of frustration that comes with being viewed as a walking philanthropist or an easy way to make some extra money with storekeepers naming whatever price they want to name. Isn't it a matter of principle I don't want to be taken as a clueless foreigner? Or if we are talking the difference of 50 cents, why not just pay it?
(More from Map Happy: United miles are being devalued on February 1st)
Sign up for Today's Best Articles in your inbox
A free daily email with the biggest news stories of the day – and the best features from TheWeek.com
A close friend — who just so happens to be a Bloomberg financial journalist — helped me reason my way out of my moral dilemma. From an economics standpoint, the right thing to do is to pay the right price. In fact, if all tourists were heavily overpaying and overtipping, it could seriously screw up the local economy. Small "charity" like that, repeated many times over, could have the very opposite effect of help. It could do damage.
I'll let her explain:
To sum it up, overpaying increases the odds of inflation. Chances are, local wages can't keep up and these goods become unaffordable for local residents, long after you've left.
(More from Map Happy: Why it's always better to pay in the local currency)
I still have a hard time grappling with it personally even though I get it. The point that made the logic of it all clear to me and that I keep returning to, however, was this:
Support local economies in a way that also respects them.
To read more posts like this, subscribe to Map Happy's newsletter or follow Map Happy on Facebook.
Create an account with the same email registered to your subscription to unlock access.