Opinion

When the experts screw up

The people who run the CDC, the Secret Service, hospitals, and other important organizations are human. Which means they make terrible mistakes.

It is comforting — and perhaps even necessary — to believe that the people in charge are far smarter and less fallible than the rest of us. But every now and then, we are reminded that the sublime competency of elected officials, religious leaders, regulators, business leaders, doctors, and scientists is an illusion. And it always comes as a shock. This week, we learned that two health-care workers caring for an Ebola patient at a Dallas hospital were infected despite elaborate precautions, and may have infected others. This week also brings the news that when an Air France flight flew into a violent thunderstorm, stalled, and crashed in 2009, killing all 228 on board, the experienced pilot had left the cockpit to take a nap because he'd stayed up the previous night fooling around with his mistress. And how about the Secret Service? Until a few weeks ago, nobody would believe a man with a knife could climb over the White House fence, burst through the open front door, and run through the building, looking for the president.

If you like, you can blame these displays of gross ineptitude on the Obama administration, Republican budget cuts, the CDC, the CIA, or the dark conspiracy of your choice. But the reality is that human folly is a constant. (See: 9/11, Iraq, the 2008 financial crash, ad infinitum.) Most of the people we entrust with great responsibility are, in fact, highly competent and dedicated, and most institutions work fairly well most of the time. But life is complicated, and even smart people screw up — often. "To err is human," Alexander Pope observed three centuries ago. How come we're so surprised every time he's proven right?

More From...

Picture of William FalkWilliam Falk
Read All
The photos we don't see
people visit the memorial set up near the Allen Premium Outlets mall.
Editor's letter

The photos we don't see

The gender wars
a chalkboard with a list of gender pronouns.
Editor's letter

The gender wars

Destroying court credibility
Supreme Court building in New York.
Editor's letter

Destroying court credibility

The worship of weapons
A woman looks up and prays at the Memorial held at The Covenant School after the shooting.
Editor's letter

The worship of weapons

Recommended

Is protected land really protected?
Grand Canyon.
Briefing

Is protected land really protected?

DOJ reportedly tells Trump he's a target of criminal investigation
Donald Trump
Famous Firsts

DOJ reportedly tells Trump he's a target of criminal investigation

Mike Pence says 'no one's above the law' but the DOJ should not indict Trump
Mike Pence and Dana Bash
Both Sides Now

Mike Pence says 'no one's above the law' but the DOJ should not indict Trump

Actor Jay Johnston arrested on Capitol attack charges
Jay Johnston in 2008
arrests

Actor Jay Johnston arrested on Capitol attack charges

Most Popular

Ban the Bible?
Holy Bible.
Briefing

Ban the Bible?

What is Mike Pence thinking?
Former Vice President Mike Pence on a motorcycle
Talking point

What is Mike Pence thinking?

Actors union votes to authorize strike
A writers strike picket line outside Sony Studios in Culver City
strike two?

Actors union votes to authorize strike