Feature

Should we be crowdsourcing the investigation of the Boston Marathon bomber?

Authorities are hoping for helpful leads from those who were in the crowd, while internet sleuths are taking the investigation into their own hands

The thousands of people streaming through Boylston Street at the time of the Boston Marathon bombings have, in the words of Boston police commissioner Edward F. Davis, made it "the most complicated crime scene" in the department's history. Still, while crowds might have made this investigation difficult, they might also be the key to solving it.

On Thursday, authorities plan to release clear video images of two suspects carrying black bags at the explosion site, according to The Boston Globe. The hope is that someone out there will recognize one or both of the men or have additional footage of them.

The FBI is glad, in this case, that we're obsessed with our smartphones — more specifically, with documenting every moment of our lives on Instagram and using video. They would, however, rather that we send the evidence to them instead of trying to crack the case on our own.

Don't tell that to Reddit. The newly created subreddit /r/findbostonbombers is already chock-full of amateur sleuths poring over photos looking to find the people responsible for the Boston bombings. From the start, the subreddit preaches caution, with disclaimers that it does "not support any form of vigilante justice" and "to equate discussion with an unambiguous implication of guilt is presumptive and hyperbolic."

In an internet vacuum, the /r/findbostonbombers subreddit is a mostly harmless rabbit hole of marked photos and amateur conjecture. The problem starts when theories go viral or are adopted by the media, something that responsible redditors are very cognizant of. One post titled "Popped up on my facebook newsfeed.. This can't happen" decries the fact that a photo dissected on Reddit was starting to go viral on Facebook — something that can have very real consequences (see: Lanza, Ryan).

Still, as Slate's Will Oremus points out, even "labeling people as 'suspicious' based on the scantest evidence can do real damage." Police in the initial stages of an investigation don't publicize every lead for a reason — a scared and angry public often doesn't hold to the "innocent until proven guilty" standard of justice.

Despite Reddit's warnings against unfounded accusations, the very existence of the /r/findbostonbombers is problematic, writes The Atlantic's Alexis Madrigal:

Investigating these bombings is just not a job for 'the crowd,' even if technology makes such collaboration possible. Even if we were to admit that Reddit was 'more efficient' in processing the influx of media around the bombing, which would be a completely baseless speculation/stretch/defense, it still wouldn't make sense to create a lawless space in which self-appointed citizens decide which other citizens have committed crimes... We have a legal system for a reason. [The Atlantic]

Reddit, for its part, seems to have higher standards than the New York Post. "BAG MEN" reads a headline over a picture of two men who people following the Reddit group eventually concluded were innocent. Gawker identified one as a Moroccan-American high school track runner who works at Subway — and who is not a suspect. The New York Post claims that authorities were circulating photos of the pair as "persons of interest," which, most likely, they also did with photos of many other people who were seen at the finish line during the bombings.

Crowdsourcing may very well play a role if and when the individual(s) who are behind the bombings are caught. Let's just hope innocent people's reputations aren't damaged in the process. 

Recommended

Boston hospital defends refusing heart transplant for patient who won't get COVID-19 vaccine
The outside of Brigham and Women's Hospital in Boston.
modern medicine

Boston hospital defends refusing heart transplant for patient who won't get COVID-19 vaccine

NYPD officer dies days after being shot on duty
A memorial for Officers Wilbert Mora and Jason Rivera.
tragedies

NYPD officer dies days after being shot on duty

OSHA tosses private employer vaccine mandate
Nurse with dose of COVID-19 vaccine.
short-lived

OSHA tosses private employer vaccine mandate

The digital SAT will be 'shorter, simpler, and perhaps easier'
Standardized test form.
drop your pencils

The digital SAT will be 'shorter, simpler, and perhaps easier'

Most Popular

7 toons about Biden's Ukraine remarks
Political Cartoon.
Feature

7 toons about Biden's Ukraine remarks

Aaron Rodgers may retire after stunning loss to 49ers
Aaron Rodgers
what a way to go out

Aaron Rodgers may retire after stunning loss to 49ers

Florida advances ban on making white people feel 'discomfort' over past racism
Ron DeSantis
Fragility

Florida advances ban on making white people feel 'discomfort' over past racism