“Nearly a decade ago, I stopped going to the office every day,” said Farhad Manjoo in Slate.com. My bosses didn’t care as long as I got my work done, and I quickly found that “without office distractions” and pointless interruptions I was far more productive. I also became a better husband and dad. That’s why I’m convinced that “Marissa Mayer has made a terrible mistake.” The CEO of Yahoo recently decreed, as part of her plan to revive the struggling Web company, that employees will no longer be able to work from home. This week Hubert Joly, CEO of struggling Best Buy, followed suit, echoing Mayer’s reasoning that only when employees are physically together in the office can they properly brainstorm and collaborate for the good of the company. That’s true to an extent, but hard research has actually shown that those of us who work from home are not only more productive than our office-bound colleagues, but are also happier overall.
“As a working mother,” said Karen Finerman in FastCompany.com, I think Mayer and Joly’s decision makes “perfect sense.” It sounds wonderful in theory to combine the joys of stay-at-home motherhood or fatherhood with a fulfilling career, but what you end up with in practice is “the worst of both worlds.” Juggling child care and work means you can’t focus properly on your job, and while you “tease” your children with your physical presence all day, “your complete lack of mental presence” often leaves them confused and upset. Employers and colleagues, meanwhile, assume you’re less committed because you’re juggling work and kids, and your career suffers. One study found that telecommuters are 50 percent less likely to be promoted. People think working at home will help them achieve a “work-life balance,” said Katie Roiphe in Slate.com. But there’s nothing “balanced” about trying to calm a tantrumming toddler while listening to a conference call and simultaneously writing an email to your boss. In this hyperconnected, workaholic world, what we really need is “more separation between work and life,” not less. That’s why most people are better off with a physical office outside the home.
Subscribe to The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
-
Drones: Will a Pentagon takeover make a difference?feature The CIA appears to be getting out of the drone business.
-
The fiscal cliff: What happens if there’s no deal?
feature Contrary to what some doomsayers have predicted, income taxes won’t go up overnight, and $500 billion won’t suddenly be sucked out of the economy.
-
The fiscal cliff: What if negotiations fail?
feature All told, $503 billion could be siphoned out of the economy, which could throw the still-weak U.S. economy back into recession.
-
Romney: Can a businessman fix the economy?
feature The Obama campaign is targeting a new line of attacks on Romney’s business background.
-
Occupy Wall Street: Will the crackdown end the movement?
feature As the police continue to dismantle the tent cities of the Occupy movement, its future as a political force is in question.
-
Jobs: Why aren’t companies hiring?
feature Nearly 15 million Americans are out of work, half of them for more than six months, and the figures aren't dropping even though employers are ringing up good profits.
-
The economy: Is the recovery for real?
feature The Great Recession is officially over. Where's the champagne?
-
Wall Street: The good times are rolling again
feature The big banks are flush with money and plan to give out billions of dollars in annual bonuses to their employees.