In the immediate wake of the horrific school shooting in Newtown, Conn., which claimed the lives of 20 children, several voices in the media eloquently and justifiably made the case for more robust gun-control laws. The general theme was that now is the time for this discussion, an impassioned rebuttal of the conservative critique that such a debate would "politicize" the tragedy. As Ezra Klein at The Washington Post put it, "That is code, essentially, for 'don't talk about reforming our gun control laws'":
The renewed push for change is also clearly a reaction to President Obama's craven reluctance to even discuss gun control during the election, despite the fact that mass shootings have, depressingly, become a regular feature of American life. The president may have gotten a pass from his liberal base during the election, when it was tacitly understood that he couldn't give the GOP a wedge to peel off voters. But not now. Not when 20 children have been killed. As a result, even Obama's tearful reaction to the shooting has only angered those who want him to do something. Michael Bloomberg, the mayor of New York City, said Obama's call for "meaningful action" was not enough. As Allison Benedikt at Slate wrote:
This is a completely understandable demand. And it's the obligation of the media to make such demands. But just imagine for a moment what would have happened if Obama had, say, called for the reinstatement of the assault weapons ban, which expired under George W. Bush. Imagine that political bomb thrown into a fevered media atmosphere in which passions are running high, in which it's hard for anyone to think clearly amid so much anger and grief. Imagine the headlines changed, the vehement Twitter arguments, and the predictable hardening of partisan positions, all centered on a single figure: Obama. Gun-rights advocates could focus their opposition on a familiar bogeyman, and we wouldn't really be talking about gun control, or even those 20 kids anymore. The issue would be fully "politicized" — in this sense, a Left vs. Right tussle divorced from the truly pressing matter at hand.
Subscribe to The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
That's not to say that Obama should wait so long that people forget why the issue of gun control is so important. This is, indeed, a moment that calls for action. But for a polarizing figure, acting in the heat of the moment could ultimately defeat the cause. The full story must come out first, and the gravity of the situation must sink in. The right course will, hopefully, come from reflection, not knee-jerk reactions. As Robert Kennedy said, quoting Aeschylus on the night of Martin Luther King's death and trying to calm a bewildered and bereaved crowd, "In our sleep, pain which cannot forget falls drop by drop upon the heart until, in our own despair, against our will, comes wisdom through the awful grace of God."
Create an account with the same email registered to your subscription to unlock access.