Opinion Brief

The Voice's 'stellar' post-Super-Bowl premiere

The season premiere of NBC's hit singing competition scored the coveted post-game time slot — and delivered with a winning show

With more than 100 million Americans tuned into the Super Bowl, it's a huge coup for any show to get the cushy post-game time slot. This year, NBC used that slot to launch the second season of reality competition series The Voice. The show puts a spin on the American Idol format by hosting "blind auditions," in which four celebrity judges — Christina Aguilera, Blake Shelton, Cee Lo Green, and Adam Levine — sit in Star Trek-like thrones with their backs to the auditioning contestant. If they like what they hear, they hit a button and turn around, welcoming the contestant onto their "team." When the show premiered last spring, critics were enamored by the chemistry between the judges and the focus on talent over spectacle. Are critics still in love with The Voice?

The Voice is still a pleasure to watch: After suffering through the dreck of America's Got Talent, the misfire of The X Factor, and the boring start to this season of American Idol, the "stellar" first episode of The Voice's second season "reinvigorated my enjoyment of singing competitions," says Dan Forcella at TV Fanatic. The Voice auditions are "revolutionary," and the early rounds are mercifully devoid of the musical trainwrecks that dominate other singing shows. Plus, the quartet of judges seem completely authentic and are utterly charming."The Voice season premiere review: To turn or not to turn"

And the performers are better than on Idol copycats: The Voice occupies a unique place in the TV singing competition universe, says Lyndsey Parker at Yahoo. Unlike American Idol and The X Factor, where a contestant's past professional experience is treated as an unforgivable sin, The Voice is unapologetic about the fact that most of its competitors are not amateurs. "These are singers poised on the edge of greatness, who just need the little extra push." Unsurprisingly, that made the performances on Sunday night far more polished and professional than on other shows."The Voice premiere: A cut above the rest?"

But the premiere had some unappealing moments: The real draw of The Voice is "the playful camaraderie" of its bickering judges, which manages to be lightly combative without crossing into toxic territory, says Michael Slezak at TV Line. But this year, the judges seem to be trying to hard to play up the personalities they carved out in season one. Aguilera, for instance, "overplays her rivalry" with Levine with cringe-inducing zingers like, "You're trying to be Justin Timberlake!" And perhaps no moment in the premiere caused viewers to squirm more than when Aguilera blatantly didn't recognize a contestant who was a former Mickey Mouse Club castmate. Awkward!"The Voice recap: The X(tina) factor"

Recommended

Rust gaffer calls out producers who 'save a dime' by hiring inexperienced crew
A poster protesting the death of Halyna Hutchins.
speaking out

Rust gaffer calls out producers who 'save a dime' by hiring inexperienced crew

The daily gossip: October 25, 2021
John Mulaney
Daily gossip

The daily gossip: October 25, 2021

Hollywood's gun problem — and ours
A gun.
Picture of Joel MathisJoel Mathis

Hollywood's gun problem — and ours

Alec Baldwin was practicing drawing 'cold' revolver when he shot cinematographer
Prop gun
Rust Shooting

Alec Baldwin was practicing drawing 'cold' revolver when he shot cinematographer

Most Popular

Day traders and Reddit loving Trump-tied SPAC
Donald Trump.
SPAC attack

Day traders and Reddit loving Trump-tied SPAC

The 'Trump app' will be the insurrection on steroids
Donald Trump.
Picture of Damon LinkerDamon Linker

The 'Trump app' will be the insurrection on steroids

Cinematographer on Baldwin film reportedly pushed for safer set conditions
Cop car leaving Bonanza Creek Ranch.
'corners were being cut'

Cinematographer on Baldwin film reportedly pushed for safer set conditions