Opinion Brief

FIFA vs. Iran: The 'ridiculous' headscarf ban

The Iranian women's soccer squad is booted from an Olympic-qualifying match because the players' hijabs violate FIFA dress code. Is that fair?

FIFA officials disqualified the Iranian women's soccer team in their Olympic-qualifying match against Jordan — dashing their hopes of competing in the 2012 games — because the players' headscarves violated the organization's dress code. Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad responded by labeling FIFA "dictators." FIFA insists its decision was largely about "safety." Besides, FIFA's rules forbid players from displaying "political, religious, commercial, or personal messages" on their uniforms. Should some allowance have been made for Iran's players?

Yes, this decision is hypocritical: FIFA may want to separate "church and field," says Nona Willis Aronowitz at Good, but it enforces its rules inconsistently. Other international players "openly flaunt their faith with cross necklaces and public prayer," and plenty of players bless themselves before games. As long as the wearing of headscarves didn't give Iran's team an unfair advantage, "who cares?""FIFA headscarf ban crushes Olympic hopes for Iranian women's soccer"

No, Iran broke the rules: The soccer team knew that hijabs violated safety rules enacted last year, say FIFA officials in a statement. Caps that cover the head "to the hairline" are allowed. But anything that extends "below the ears to cover the neck" is not. The Iranian delegation "understood this," and the headscarves the players wore anyway instead of the smaller FIFA-approved head coverings were an "infringement of the laws of the game." Officials were right to cancel the game."World soccer officials defend hijab ban after Iranian team forfeits match"

In any case, this decision compromises the Olympics: Thanks a lot, FIFA, says Alyssa Rosenberg at ThinkProgress. You've cast a pall over the upcoming London summer games, by "pushing women out of an arena" where they can actually command respect. Banning the Iranian team is "counterproductive," and forces them to choose between respecting their faith and playing a sport that allows them to demonstrate "physical prowess and strategic intelligence.""FIFA headscarf ban casts a pall on the Olympics, is generally ridiculous"

Recommended

Washington State football coach out after not complying with COVID-19 vaccine mandate
Nick Rolovich.
vaccine mandates

Washington State football coach out after not complying with COVID-19 vaccine mandate

Chicago Sky wins 1st WNBA championship
Chicago Sky players celebrate their win.
congratulations

Chicago Sky wins 1st WNBA championship

Jon Gruden resigns as Raiders coach amid fallout over racist, homophobic emails
Jon Gruden.
bye

Jon Gruden resigns as Raiders coach amid fallout over racist, homophobic emails

Oldest living former MLB player Eddie Robinson dies at 100
Eddie Robinson.
rest in peace

Oldest living former MLB player Eddie Robinson dies at 100

Most Popular

Democrats' months of dithering
President Biden.
Picture of Ryan CooperRyan Cooper

Democrats' months of dithering

The American 'Great Resignation' by the numbers
Help wanted sign
Help Wanted

The American 'Great Resignation' by the numbers

Senate Republicans block Joe Manchin's voting rights bill
Joe Manchin
No Joe

Senate Republicans block Joe Manchin's voting rights bill