Opinion Brief

Libya airstrikes: Should Gadhafi be a target?

Military officials insist the U.S. and its allies are not trying to kill Libyan leader Moammar Gadhafi. But commentators wonder if that rhetoric matches the reality

President Obama says that Libyan dictator Moammar Gadhafi must go, and British government ministers suggest he would be a "legitimate target." But, while Western airstrikes have blasted Gadhafi's compound in Tripoli, Defense Secretary Robert Gates says no cruise missiles or bombs are being aimed directly at him, and British military commanders say that going after Gadhafi specifically is prohibited under the United Nations Security Council resolution authorizing the use of force to protect Libyan civilians. If we're not aiming at Gadhafi, should we be?

It would be illegal to assassinate Gadhafi: Allied warships and planes are not shooting directly at Gadhafi, says Libya expert Charles Gurdon, as quoted by AOL News, because we can't. Legally, no "Western leader can sanction the assassination of another leader." Allied forces "wouldn't be upset" if a bomb happened to land on Gadhafi, but they have to content themselves with blowing up his artillery and aircraft to "make it impossible for the regime to wage war on the people."
"Where is Gadhafi hiding this time as missiles strike Libya?"

If we're not targeting Gadhafi, we should be: This is war, says Ed Morrissey at Hot Air. And the reason we're fighting is to protect Libyans from Gadhafi. That makes him the most legitimate target of all, because taking out the guy who is commanding loyalist forces will "go much farther toward ending the siege of Benghazi than strafing infantry and armor in and around the city."
"Gadhafi compound struck by Western forces, Gadhafi missing?"

Of course we're aiming at Gadhafi. We just can't admit it: With missiles landing on the Libyan dictator's house, the claim that we "are not 'targeting' Gadhafi himself rings false," says Jason Ditz at Antiwar.com. The Obama administration has to say it's not trying to kill Gadhafi to reassure the Arab League — vital allies in this fight — that we're not going beyond the U.N. mandate. The reality is just "getting obscured by the rhetoric."
"Is Gadhafi a target of U.S.-led attacks? Depends whom you ask"

Recommended

Is the U.S. culpable in Mexico's deadly migrant fire?
Memorial.
Today's big question

Is the U.S. culpable in Mexico's deadly migrant fire?

Finland clears final hurdle for NATO membership, will be admitted by July
Finnish President Sauli Niinisto and Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan
Done Deal

Finland clears final hurdle for NATO membership, will be admitted by July

Honeybees help gather data about a city's health
Honeybee on flower.
buzz buzz

Honeybees help gather data about a city's health

Pope Francis hospitalized with respiratory infection
Pope Francis.
get well soon

Pope Francis hospitalized with respiratory infection

Most Popular

The snowmelt in California could cause a long-lost lake to re-emerge
flooding in Corcoran, California.
lost lake

The snowmelt in California could cause a long-lost lake to re-emerge

The 8 most bizarre moments of Gwyneth Paltrow's ski crash trial
Gwyneth Paltrow
downhill

The 8 most bizarre moments of Gwyneth Paltrow's ski crash trial

Jennifer Aniston: Friends is now 'offensive' to a 'whole generation'
Jennifer Aniston
the one where they get canceled

Jennifer Aniston: Friends is now 'offensive' to a 'whole generation'