Feature

Should Halloween be off-limits for sex offenders?

A California county tells people convicted of molesting children not to put up decorations or give out candy. Is that unfair or a smart precaution?

With Halloween fast approaching, leaders in Tulare County, Calif., have passed a law barring anyone convicted of sexual crimes against children from decorating their homes and passing out candy to trick-or-treaters. County supervisors called it a simple safety precaution, but critics warned that courts might see the rule as a violation of the sex offenders' First Amendment rights. Is this an easy way to make a child-oriented holiday safer, or is the local government overstepping its authority by saying who can and can't celebrate Halloween?

They mean well, but the ban is wrong: "The impulse is certainly understandable," says Tracy Clark-Flory at Salon. Crossing sex offenders' homes off the "trick-or-treating route" will ease parents' minds. But these people "have served their time." It doesn't seem entirely "fair" — or even legal — for the local government to single them out like this."No Halloween for sex offenders"

Protecting kids is priority No. 1: The county supervisors are perfectly aware of the objections, says J. Brown at California City News. They obviously feel that keeping children safe is their first concern and that this is "an important preventive step." Besides, it is no big imposition — all sex offenders have to do is turn off their outside lights on Halloween night and ignore the doorbell if trick-or-treaters come calling."Supervisors approve ban"

This is one Halloween fear that has been exaggerated: "We do need to be protected from sex offenders," says Tulare County Public Defender Michael Sheltzer, as quoted in the Porterville, CA, Recorder. But the number of sex crimes against children reported locally on Halloween is "zero." The ban "addresses the fear of crime rather than the actual risk of crime," so at best, all parents will get is a "sense of false security.""County forbids sex offenders from giving candy to kids on Halloween"

Recommended

Biden, Putin express openness to cybercriminal exchange
Joe Biden.
depends on what you mean

Biden, Putin express openness to cybercriminal exchange

Netanyahu goes 'scorched earth'
Benjamin Netanyahu.
loose cannon

Netanyahu goes 'scorched earth'

Biden says he's 'satisfied' with G7's final stance on China
G7 summit.
that'll do for now

Biden says he's 'satisfied' with G7's final stance on China

10 things you need to know today: June 13, 2021
G7 summit in Cornwall.
Daily briefing

10 things you need to know today: June 13, 2021

Most Popular

7 toons about the Dems' Joe Manchin problem
Political Cartoon.
Feature

7 toons about the Dems' Joe Manchin problem

Bad for Democrats. Good for democracy?
A voter.
Picture of Joel MathisJoel Mathis

Bad for Democrats. Good for democracy?

Texas governor claims Texas will build its own border wall
Greg Abbott
Abbott's Wall

Texas governor claims Texas will build its own border wall