Opinion Brief

BP oil spill: Accident, or crime?

Environmental law experts say criminal charges are likely over the Gulf of Mexico oil disaster. Are they warranted?

Legal analysts say the government is likely to file criminal charges against at least one of the companies connected to the massive oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico. Well-owner BP and its partners — TransOcean, which operated the drilling rig that exploded, and Halliburton, which installed a well plug that failed — have pointed fingers at one another in congressional hearings; each denies being primarily at fault for the spill. Is the Gulf disaster just an unfortunate accident — or is it a crime? (Watch Rep. Bart Stupak cite BP's "culture of incompetence")

With evidence piling up, criminal charges are a given: Investigators are turning up clear "evidence of negligence," says Gus Lubin in Business Insider, "including a blowout preventer that was out of batteries and hadn't been properly tested." So, sit tight — it's "obvious" someone is going to face criminal charges. The only question is, who?"Forget that $75 million liability cap: Criminal charges in BP spill are "very likely" says former DOJ official"

Those charges need to entail some serious jail time: This is the "worst case criminal negligence" I've ever seen, says Tom Degan in LA Progressive. There's equipment available that could have prevented the leak, but these companies, out of "greed and stupidity," couldn't be bothered to make sure the well was safe. Somebody should go to prison for this, but, given the government's history of coddling the oil industry, "don't hold your breath.""Oil spills and B movies"

Criminal charges don't seem warranted: The shocking revelations of the missteps that let this happen "are the grits and grease" of standard civil lawsuits, says Tulane University environmental law professor Oliver Houck, as quoted by McClatchy. But "to get into criminal land," the government has to prove the companies "knew that the short cuts they were taking brought a high probability of serious risk." And there's no proof of that."Criminal charges likely from Gulf oil spill, legal experts say"

Recommended

Great Britain has its 1st Catholic prime minister. Surprise!
Boris Johnson, Carrie Symonds
Things that make you go hmmmmm...

Great Britain has its 1st Catholic prime minister. Surprise!

Biden suspends Trump's 25 percent tariff on Scotch whisky
Scotch
Slàinte mhath

Biden suspends Trump's 25 percent tariff on Scotch whisky

Almost all operations shut down as COVID-19 outbreak hits U.S. Embassy in Kabul
The U.S. Embassy in Kabul.
coronavirus crisis

Almost all operations shut down as COVID-19 outbreak hits U.S. Embassy in Kabul

Biden's Putin meeting rehabilitated his image in Russia
Joe Biden
Image upgrade

Biden's Putin meeting rehabilitated his image in Russia

Most Popular

7 toons about the Dems' Joe Manchin problem
Political Cartoon.
Feature

7 toons about the Dems' Joe Manchin problem

Bernie Sanders wants to know if cannabis reporter is 'stoned' right now
Bernie Sanders.
Sounds dope

Bernie Sanders wants to know if cannabis reporter is 'stoned' right now

Georgia election workers reportedly received a 'torrent' of threats
Trump rally.
The big lie

Georgia election workers reportedly received a 'torrent' of threats