"There are no winners in war", was Neville Chamberlain's assessment in 1938, and that appears to hold true today as a ceasefire between Israel and Hamas inches closer.
The terror group's assault on 7 October 2023 marked the launch of a bid to devastate Israeli defences, but "that has demonstrably failed", said The Times, "at the cost of tens of thousands of Palestinian lives". But Israel "has also demonstrably failed" in its war aims to destroy Hamas and secure the release of hostages.
'Israel's defender' For a long time, Israel's Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu "did not want" the newly negotiated peace deal, said Amos Harel in Haaretz. Controlling the Gaza Strip's border with Egypt "was presented as an eternal security requirement for Israel", but the speed with which Netanyahu conceded on this issue under pressure from Donald Trump "attests to the real weight of this argument". The Israeli public "will be surprised when it finds out what the person who says he wishes to be remembered as Israel's defender had to concede during the negotiations".
On the face of it, the deal meets "almost completely all the demands put by Hamas during the war" said Motasem Dalloul on Middle East Monitor, "and it is very clear that even a single demand from Netanyahu’s has not been met". Equally, Netanyahu's actions over the past 15 months have been turning Israel into a "pariah state" in the West.
'Axis of Resistance has been crippled' But Israel's strength in the Middle East has only been strengthened. While Hamas is still standing, Netanyahu "can point to his other successes in the war, such as the killing of Hamas’s top leadership structure", said Middle East specialist Ian Parmeter on The Conversation. Additionally, Hezbollah has been crushed, Iran weakened and the regime of Bashar al-Assad has collapsed in Syria.
The "network of allies and proxies that Tehran called the Axis of Resistance has been crippled," said the BBC's Jeremy Bowen. But joy over any potential ceasefire may be short-lived. In Tel Aviv, it was "a bittersweet moment for the families and supporters of Israeli hostages, living and dead". And in Gaza, said John Davenport in Newsweek, there may be "no escape at all" for the Palestinian people "trapped in the hell on Earth that Netanyahu and Hamas together, like two dancers in a macabre death show, have made".
|